Building bonus recovery in Italy: beneficiaries, suppliers and transferees

With the superbonus and the other building bonuses transferred or applied as an invoice discount, a single deduction can involve several parties: the owner who had the works carried out, the contractor that granted the discount, and the bank or company that bought the credit. When the Italian Revenue Agency challenges the incentive, the first question in building bonus recovery (recupero dei bonus edilizi) is: who has to repay what?

This guide explains how this recovery works, when suppliers and transferees are liable, what changes if the credit is non-existent and what risks arise from the criminal seizure of credits.

In brief

  • Building bonus recovery is directed first of all at the beneficiary who exercised the option, with interest and penalties.
  • Suppliers and transferees are liable for irregular use of the credit and, jointly with the beneficiary, only if they took part in the violation with intent or gross negligence.
  • For credits offset against taxes, the tax credit recovery notice applies, with deadlines of 5 or 8 years depending on whether the credit is undue (non spettante) or non-existent (inesistente).
  • For non-existent credits the recovery notice is not preceded by the pre-assessment hearing.
  • In judgment no. 6532/2026 the Court of Cassation confirmed that credits can be seized even from a transferee acting in good faith.

Who is liable in building bonus recovery

Article 121 of Decree-Law 34/2020 distinguishes between the parties involved in building bonus recovery. If the requirements for the deduction are not met, the Agency recovers the amount from the beneficiary, that is, the person who incurred the expenses and exercised the option, with interest and penalties. Suppliers and transferees, on the other hand, are liable for any use of the credit in an irregular manner or in an amount greater than that received.

Following the amendments made by Decree-Law 115/2022, suppliers and transferees are jointly liable with the beneficiary only if they took part in the violation with intent or gross negligence. Gross negligence means glaring carelessness, such as buying credits without any documentation on the works.

PartyWhen it is liableWhat it can prove
Beneficiary (client)If the requirements for the deduction are not metWorks carried out, building permits, sworn technical statements, actual expenses and regularity of the options
Supplier that granted the discountIrregular use of the credit or participation with intent or gross negligenceExecution of the works, site accounts, relations with the client
Transferee (bank, company, private individual)Irregular use of the credit or participation with intent or gross negligenceDue diligence at purchase: documents obtained, checks carried out, consistent price

The diligent transferee

Decree-Law 11/2023 listed the documents that the transferee should obtain and keep: building permit, preliminary notification, land registry extract, invoices and payment receipts, sworn technical statements, compliance certificate (visto di conformità), works contract and, for the superbonus, the ENEA receipt. The same decree specified that the absence of one of these documents is not, on its own, enough to prove gross negligence.

Those who bought credits with a complete file and at a market-consistent price have good arguments to rule out their joint liability in building bonus recovery. Those who bought them at unusual prices, from newly formed entities or without documentation, are more exposed.

Building bonus recovery: deadlines and hearing

When a credit arising from building bonuses has been offset, the Agency proceeds with the tax credit recovery notice under Article 38-bis of Presidential Decree 600/1973. The deadline is 31 December of the fifth year after the credit was used for undue credits, and of the eighth year for non-existent ones.

The distinction matters a great deal. A credit arising from works never carried out or from false invoices is non-existent: in this case the recovery notice is not preceded by the pre-assessment hearing (Article 7-bis, Decree-Law 39/2024) and the penalty for violations from 1 September 2024 is 70%. If, instead, the works exist and a requirement is missing, for example an irregular sworn technical statement, the credit is as a rule undue: a 5-year deadline, a 25% penalty and the right to a draft assessment (schema di atto) for challenges on the merits.

Criminal seizure of credits

In investigations into building bonus fraud, the Public Prosecutor can request the preventive seizure of credits held in the taxpayer’s tax credit account (cassetto fiscale). In judgment no. 6532 of 17 February 2026 the criminal division of the Court of Cassation confirmed that “preventive” seizure, aimed at stopping the offence, can affect credits even when they were bought by a third party in good faith, because it concerns the link between the credit and the offence, not the fault of the holder.

As long as the seizure remains in place, the credit cannot be used or transferred. The transferee’s good faith may, however, count for seizure aimed at confiscation and, on the tax side, to rule out joint liability in building bonus recovery.

How to build the defence in building bonus recovery

  1. identify the role of the party receiving the notice: beneficiary, supplier or transferee;
  2. check the deadlines: is the credit challenged as non-existent or undue? Did the notice arrive in time?
  3. check the hearing: for challenges on the merits of existing credits, a draft assessment was required;
  4. reconstruct the works with documents, photos, progress reports, building permits and sworn technical statements;
  5. for the transferee, document the checks carried out at the time of purchase and the price paid;
  6. assess the options: settlement agreement (accertamento con adesione), payment with reduced penalties or appeal, also in parallel with any criminal proceedings.

Frequently asked questions

I bought building bonus credits and they are now being challenged: do I have to repay them?

It depends. The transferee is liable if it used the credit irregularly or took part in the violation with intent or gross negligence. If it acted with due diligence, it has good arguments to rule out its liability.

Is the supplier that granted the invoice discount at risk of building bonus recovery?

Yes, if it used the credit irregularly or took part in the violation with intent or gross negligence, for example by invoicing works that were not carried out.

How long does the Agency have to start building bonus recovery?

Until 31 December of the fifth year after the credit was used, if undue, or of the eighth year, if non-existent.

Does the seizure of credits also affect those acting in good faith?

Yes: for preventive seizure aimed at stopping the offence, the Court of Cassation held that the transferee’s good faith is irrelevant. It remains relevant, however, for confiscation and for tax liability.

Do I also need a defence lawyer in the criminal proceedings?

If there are criminal proceedings, a criminal lawyer is needed. We handle the tax side and coordinate the defence with the lawyer.

Sources

  • Article 119 and Article 121(4)-(6), Decree-Law 34 of 19 May 2020
  • Decree-Law 115 of 9 August 2022 (joint liability for intent or gross negligence)
  • Decree-Law 11 of 16 February 2023 (transferee’s documentation)
  • Article 38-bis, Presidential Decree 600/1973; Article 7-bis, Decree-Law 39 of 29 March 2024
  • Article 13, Legislative Decree 471/1997, as amended by Legislative Decree 87/2024
  • Revenue Agency Circulars no. 23/E and no. 33/E of 2022
  • Court of Cassation, criminal division, judgment no. 6532 of 17 February 2026
  • Consolidated legislation (in Italian): Normattiva; official rulings, circulars and forms: Agenzia delle Entrate

In building bonus recovery each party has a different position and different arguments. Clarifying your role at once and gathering the right documents is the best way to avoid paying for other people’s mistakes.

Studio Savia · Tax assessment defence

Have you received a building bonus recovery notice?

Send us the notice: the first reading is free and we reply within 2 working days with the available options.

Request a first reading

Prefer to talk it through? Call the firm on +39 011 349 0809 (Mon–Fri 8:30 am–1:00 pm / 2:00–5:30 pm CET) or message us on WhatsApp.