Many companies that used the research and development tax credit (credito ricerca e sviluppo) between 2015 and 2019 are now facing tax audits, audit reports and tax credit recovery notices. In most cases the Italian Revenue Agency does not dispute that the costs were incurred, but whether the activities were really “research and development”.
2026 changed the picture: the Council of State ruled that the criteria of the Frascati Manual cannot be applied retroactively, and the Court of Cassation narrowed the scope of the “non-existent” credit. This guide explains what this means in practice and how to build the defence.
In brief
- Challenges to the research and development tax credit mainly concern the nature of the activities, eligible costs and documentation.
- In judgment no. 5627 of 14 July 2026, the Council of State held that, for the years before 2020, the five criteria of the Frascati Manual do not apply; the applicable rules are Article 3 of Decree-Law 145/2013 and the Ministerial Decree of 27 May 2015.
- Under the 2025 MEF policy guidance, the lack of technical qualities makes the credit undue (non spettante): a 5-year deadline, a 25% penalty for violations from 1 September 2024 and a mandatory pre-assessment hearing.
- The certification under Article 23 of Decree-Law 73/2022 is binding on the tax authorities as to the classification of the activities.
- Voluntary repayment is closed: the last window expired on 3 June 2025.
Table of contents
Why the research and development tax credit is being challenged
From 2015 to 2019 the research and development tax credit was governed by Article 3 of Decree-Law 145/2013 and the Ministerial Decree of 27 May 2015: an incremental credit, calculated on the excess of expenditure over the average for the three years 2012-2014. From 2020, Law 160/2019 and the Ministerial Decree of 26 May 2020 introduced new rules that expressly refer to the OECD Frascati Manual.
Many audits of the years 2015-2019 applied the criteria of the new regime retroactively, challenging for example software development, the improvement of existing products or activities entrusted to external consultants. The audit often starts with a report by the Guardia di Finanza and ends with a tax credit recovery notice.
What the Council of State decided in 2026
In judgment no. 5627 of 14 July 2026 the Council of State upheld decision no. 15039/2025 of the Lazio Regional Administrative Court (TAR Lazio), which had annulled a refusal of certification by the Ministry of Enterprises for the years 2017-2019. The principle is clear: the five requirements of the 2015 Frascati Manual, given weight by Law 160/2019 and the Ministerial Decree of 26 May 2020, apply going forward and cannot be used as a benchmark for earlier years.
The judgment does not automatically validate the research and development tax credit and is not binding on the tax courts, but it carries strong persuasive weight. The company must still prove that the activities actually took place, that they went beyond ordinary work, that the costs are eligible and that the documentation is in order.
The rules that apply year by year
| Years | Rules | What matters for the defence |
|---|---|---|
| 2015-2019 | Article 3, Decree-Law 145/2013 and Ministerial Decree of 27 May 2015 | The categories of activity provided for at the time; according to the Council of State, the five-criteria Frascati test does not apply |
| From 2020 | Article 1(198)-(209), Law 160/2019 and Ministerial Decree of 26 May 2020 | Frascati criteria referred to by the law; technical report and certification of expenses |
| All years | Article 23, Decree-Law 73/2022 (certification) | A certification issued by a body entered in the official register is binding on the tax authorities as to the classification of the activities |
Research and development tax credit: undue or non-existent
For the research and development tax credit this distinction is decisive. The MEF policy guidance of 1 July 2025 states that, if the subjective and objective requirements are met, the lack of technical qualities required by detailed sources makes the credit undue. In order no. 13508 of 9 May 2026 the Court of Cassation confirmed that the longer eight-year deadline applies only to credits that are truly non-existent, that is, lacking the constituent requirement.
The practical consequence is significant: if a credit used in 2019 is undue, the recovery notice had to be served by 31 December 2024. Many notices issued later, on the grounds that the credit was “non-existent”, should be checked on precisely this point. The general rules on deadlines and penalties are covered in our guide on the tax credit recovery notice.
Certification of the activities
Article 23 of Decree-Law 73/2022 and the Prime Ministerial Decree (DPCM) of 15 September 2023 introduced the certification of research and development, innovation and design activities, issued by bodies entered in the register kept by the Ministry of Enterprises. Certification is optional, but it is binding on the tax authorities as to the technical classification of the activities, unless the facts were misrepresented.
Certification does not attest the existence or the amount of the research and development tax credit: it concerns only the nature of the activities. As a rule it cannot be obtained once the violation has already been established in an audit report or a notice. For the years 2015-2019 the certifier must apply the rules in force at the time, as clarified by the Council of State.
How to build the defence
When challenging a recovery notice on the research and development tax credit, we work in this order:
- deadlines: check whether the credit is challenged as non-existent or undue and whether the notice was served in time;
- hearing: for challenges on the merits the office had to send a draft assessment; if it is missing, the notice can be annulled;
- findings: separate those based only on the Frascati criteria from independent ones, such as whether the activities actually took place and whether the costs are related and reasonable;
- evidence: technical reports, project documents, staff hours, contracts with commissioned parties, invoices and the accounting certification of expenses;
- burden of proof: since the 2022 reform the office must prove in court the facts on which its claim is based (Article 7(5-bis), Legislative Decree 546/1992);
- penalties: uncertainty about the applicable rules may exclude or reduce them.
In court it may be useful to request a court-appointed technical expert, framing the question on the categories of activity in force in the years under dispute and not on the Frascati test. Before appealing, a settlement agreement (accertamento con adesione) can be considered, which suspends the deadlines for 90 days.
Voluntary repayment
The voluntary repayment procedure under Article 5 of Decree-Law 146/2021 allowed companies to return the credit without penalties or interest. After several extensions, the last window closed on 3 June 2025. For those who chose to pay in three instalments, the last payment remains due on 16 December 2026. Today, for notices already served, the ordinary options apply: settlement agreement, payment with reduced penalties or appeal.
Frequently asked questions
Does the Council of State judgment annul recovery notices on the research and development tax credit?
No, not automatically. It is an authoritative precedent on the criteria that apply to the years 2015-2019, but each notice must be appealed and the activities must still be proven.
Is a challenged research and development tax credit non-existent or undue?
As a rule, if the activities and costs exist and the dispute concerns their technical classification, the credit is undue. This means a 5-year deadline for the recovery notice and lower penalties.
Can I still apply for certification?
As a rule, no, if the violation has already been established in an audit report or a notice. It is useful, however, for years not yet audited.
Do I need a technical expert for the defence?
Often, yes. The defence combines tax and technical aspects: we work with industry experts to reconstruct the research and development activities carried out.
Does the research and development tax credit still exist?
Yes. The rules of Law 160/2019 have been extended with different rates; for future investments it is advisable to consider certification from the start.
Sources
- Article 3, Decree-Law 145 of 23 December 2013 and Ministerial Decree of 27 May 2015
- Article 1(198)-(209), Law 160 of 27 December 2019 and Ministerial Decree of 26 May 2020
- Article 23, Decree-Law 73 of 21 June 2022 and Prime Ministerial Decree of 15 September 2023 (certification)
- Article 5(7)-(12), Decree-Law 146 of 21 October 2021 (voluntary repayment)
- Council of State, Section VI, judgment no. 5627 of 14 July 2026; TAR Lazio, judgment no. 15039/2025
- Court of Cassation, order no. 13508 of 9 May 2026; Joint Divisions, judgment no. 34419/2023
- Policy guidance of the Deputy Minister of Economy of 1 July 2025
- Consolidated legislation (in Italian): Normattiva; official rulings, circulars and forms: Agenzia delle Entrate
With the research and development tax credit the outcome often turns on dates and classifications: an undue credit served late can no longer be recovered. It is advisable to have the notice read before deciding whether to pay.
Studio Savia · Tax assessment defence
Is your research and development tax credit being challenged?
Send us the notice or the audit report: the first reading is free and we reply within 2 working days with the available options.
Request a first readingPrefer to talk it through? Call the firm on +39 011 349 0809 (Mon–Fri 8:30 am–1:00 pm / 2:00–5:30 pm CET) or message us on WhatsApp.
