Tax litigation in Italy: how it works and how to challenge a notice from the Agenzia delle Entrate

Tax litigation in Italy does not start in a courtroom. It starts the day a notice arrives from the Agenzia delle Entrate (the Italian Revenue Agency), from Agenzia delle Entrate-Riscossione (the collection agency) or from a municipality, and from that moment every choice has a price and a deadline.

This guide explains how the path from audit to judgment works, which tools let you close a dispute earlier and at lower cost, what a case before the Corte di giustizia tributaria (the Italian tax court) costs and how long it takes and, above all, how to decide whether a notice should be accepted, negotiated or challenged. It applies to companies, professionals, private individuals and foreign businesses with an Italian VAT position, and it links to the Studio’s guides on each single step.

In brief

  • From the service of a tax assessment notice you have 60 days to choose: pay with reduced penalties (acquiescence), negotiate (settlement agreement, which suspends the deadline for 90 days), ask for cancellation (self-review) or file an appeal. Silence makes the notice final.
  • Before the notice there are the mandatory preliminary hearing (60 days to reply to the draft notice) and voluntary disclosure: these are the moments when you save the most.
  • The case is heard by the tax courts, is fully electronic, requires a licensed defender above 3,000 euros, a court fee from 30 to 1,500 euros and, in 2025, ended wholly or partly in the taxpayer’s favour in about one case out of two.
  • Before settling an assessment, assess its merits under criminal law too: the thresholds for tax offences and the wording used by the office can turn a quick settlement into a criminal complaint.
  • From 1 January 2027 the procedural rules move into the consolidated Tax Justice Code (Legislative Decree 175/2024), without changing their substance.

What tax litigation in Italy is, and when it really begins

Strictly speaking, tax litigation in Italy is the court process through which a taxpayer challenges an act of the tax administration: an assessment notice (avviso di accertamento), a payment demand (cartella di pagamento), a refund denial, a mortgage registration. In practice, however, the game is played much earlier, and those who face it only when the notice arrives have already lost the best opportunities.

The typical path has three phases. The first is the audit: a questionnaire, a summons, an on-site inspection, a bank enquiry. The powers of the Agenzia delle Entrate and of the Guardia di Finanza at this stage, and their limits, are explained in our guide on tax assessment powers in Italy. The second phase is the preliminary hearing (contraddittorio): since 2024 the office, before issuing any challengeable act, must send a draft notice and allow at least 60 days for observations and documents (art. 6-bis of the Taxpayer’s Charter, Law 212/2000). A notice issued without this hearing, where it was due, can be annulled.

The third phase is the notice itself: the assessment notice, which today is also an enforceable title, or the payment demand for automated and formal checks, preceded by a courtesy notice (avviso bonario). From here the 60 days start. Understanding which phase you are in is the first thing to do, because each phase has its own tools: before the notice you can regularise voluntarily, during the hearing you can persuade the office, after the notice you can settle, request self-review or appeal. Whoever receives a demand or an assessment should therefore, first of all, date the act and its service.

The 60 days: the options when a notice arrives

From the service of an assessment notice, 60 days run; they are extended by the summer suspension (1 to 31 August) and by a further 90 days if you file a request for a settlement agreement. In that time the taxpayer has five options, which are not rigidly alternative to each other, and choosing among them is the first real step of tax litigation in Italy.

OptionWhen it makes senseEffect on penaltiesDeadline
AcquiescenceThe claim is well founded and you want to close at onceReduced to one third60 days from service, with payment
Settlement agreementThe claim is only partly founded or the amount is debatableReduced to one third of the minimum, payable in instalmentsRequest within 60 days; suspends the deadline for 90 days
Self-reviewThe notice contains an obvious error (wrong person, calculation, payment already made)The notice is cancelled or correctedNo deadline, but it does not suspend the 60 days for the appeal
AppealThe notice is wrong on the merits or in form and the other routes are not enoughDecided in court; conciliation reduces them to 40-50%60 days from service (plus suspensions)
Instalment planThe only problem is liquidityNo reduction, but it avoids vehicle seizure and mortgageAfter the demand or the enforceable notice
No actionNever advisableFull penaltiesThe notice becomes final and goes to collection

The options can be combined: a settlement request buys time to evaluate an appeal; a self-review request can accompany the appeal without replacing it; an instalment plan can be requested even after challenging the notice, for the part the Agency can collect anyway while the case is pending. The only choice that closes every door is silence.

Deflationary tools: close earlier, and pay less

The legislator prefers that tax litigation in Italy does not reach the courtroom, and proves it with discounts. Voluntary disclosure (ravvedimento operoso) is the tool of those who spot the error before the office does: penalties fall to a fraction of the minimum, from one tenth within 30 days to one seventh after a year, and since 2024 voluntary disclosure is possible even after an audit report or a draft notice, with less generous reductions. It is no longer possible after the assessment notice has been served.

The preliminary hearing is free and often decisive: observations on the draft notice oblige the office to explain why it rejects them, and an assessment that ignores documents produced at that stage is born fragile. Since 2024 there is also settlement on the audit report, with penalties reduced to one sixth, for those who want to close immediately after the inspection.

The settlement agreement (accertamento con adesione) is a formal negotiation with the office: the taxable base is discussed, a deed is signed, penalties fall to one third of the minimum and payment can be spread over eight quarterly instalments (sixteen above 50,000 euros). It makes sense when the claim is partly founded and the evidence to the contrary is weak. Acquiescence is the version without negotiation: you accept the notice as it is, paying within the 60 days, and penalties are reduced to one third.

Self-review (autotutela) changed with the reform of the Taxpayer’s Charter: in cases of manifest error (wrong person, calculation, tax, payment already made, documents missing and later produced) cancellation is an obligation for the office, and silence or refusal can be challenged before the court. In other cases it remains discretionary, to be requested with a reasoned application that does not, however, stop the appeal deadline.

Finally, once in court, conciliation: the parties can settle out of court or at the hearing and, since 2024, the judge can propose it. Penalties fall to 40% of the minimum at first instance and 50% on appeal; a party that refuses the judge’s proposal and then obtains less pays increased costs. The former complaint and mediation procedure no longer exists for appeals filed from 4 January 2024.

How the Italian tax court process works today

The case is heard by the Corte di giustizia tributaria di primo grado of the province where the issuing office is based, and on appeal by the regional Corte di giustizia tributaria di secondo grado; the last instance is the Corte di cassazione (Supreme Court). The procedure is fully electronic (SIGIT), the appeal is served on the authority by certified e-mail (PEC) and filed within 30 days with the court fee. Above 3,000 euros in dispute a licensed defender is required: a lawyer, a chartered accountant (commercialista) or an accounting expert. Disputes up to 5,000 euros are decided by a single judge, the others by a panel of three.

Three rules introduced in tax litigation in Italy by the 2022 and 2023 reforms matter more than all the others. First: the burden of proof lies with the administration, which must prove in court the facts on which it bases its claim, and the notice must be annulled if the proof is missing or contradictory; for refunds, instead, the burden lies with the taxpayer. Second: written witness evidence is now admitted, where it was previously forbidden. Third: the judge can suspend the notice if payment would cause serious harm, deciding quickly.

In the meantime the Agency may collect one third of the assessed taxes; after an unfavourable first-instance judgment, two thirds; after the appeal, the rest. The hearing may be public or remote; the judgment, often in simplified form, arrives on average within a year of filing in the most efficient courts and in two or three years elsewhere. The losing party pays the other side’s costs, as assessed by the judge. The appeal must be served within 60 days of service of the judgment, or within six months of its filing if nobody serves it: this is why, when you win, it pays to serve the judgment on the office at once and shorten the period of uncertainty.

From 1 January 2027 these rules, today in Legislative Decree 546/1992, are gathered in the consolidated Tax Justice Code (Legislative Decree 175/2024), whose entry into force was postponed by one year by the “Milleproroghe” decree: the article numbers change (challengeable acts move from art. 19 to art. 65, the appeal deadline from art. 21 to art. 67), the rules do not.

How much it costs and how long it takes

In tax litigation in Italy the court fee (contributo unificato) depends on the value of the dispute, that is the tax in dispute net of penalties and interest: 30 euros up to 2,582.28 euros, 60 up to 5,000, 120 up to 25,000, 250 up to 75,000, 500 up to 200,000 and 1,500 above that. Add the defender’s fee, agreed in advance and depending on value and complexity, and the risk of paying the other side’s costs. For a dispute worth 20,000 euros of tax, the overall cost of a first-instance case usually falls between 2,000 and 5,000 euros, partly recoverable if you win.

The 2025 figures for tax litigation in Italy help with the decision. About 155,500 appeals reached the first-instance courts, 14.6% fewer than the year before, and more than 173,000 judgments were filed for a value of 15 billion euros; judgments wholly in favour of the administration were 47.9%, those wholly in favour of the taxpayer 29%, partial ones about 23%. On appeal the picture is similar. Conciliations grew by 49%. Before the Supreme Court a tax case lasts 52 months on average. In short: a taxpayer who appeals with a well-founded case obtains satisfaction, in whole or in part, more than once in two, but must allow for long timescales if the dispute reaches the last instance.

When it pays to appeal and when it does not

In tax litigation in Italy the right question is not “am I right?” but “how much is being right worth, how much does it cost to prove it, and what do I risk in the meantime?”. An appeal pays when the notice has a serious formal defect (service, reasoning, hearing omitted, time-barred), when on the merits the claim rests on presumptions that the documents disprove, when the amount justifies the costs and when the issue will recur in later years, because a favourable judgment also stops future assessments on the same point.

It does not pay when the claim is substantially correct and only the amount is in dispute (the settlement agreement is better), when the defect is a clerical error (self-review is better, with the appeal as a fallback) or when the value is so low that the court fee and the time are worth more than the stake.

There is, however, a third and frequent case: the notice is unfounded but built to frighten, with heavy legal characterisations and inflated amounts that serve to negotiate downwards. Accepting such a notice “to close the matter” is often the most expensive mistake, because the settlement fixes a taxable base that stays on record for the following years and, above certain thresholds, ends up with the public prosecutor. The assessment of the merits must be made before signing anything.

The criminal risk behind a tax assessment

An assessment, and the tax litigation that follows it, is not only a question of money. When the evaded tax exceeds the thresholds of Legislative Decree 74/2000 (100,000 euros for an inaccurate return, 50,000 for an omitted return, 250,000 for unpaid VAT, 150,000 for unpaid withholding taxes, 50,000 for undue offsetting) the office must file a crime report, and for invoices for non-existent transactions there is no threshold at all. Criminal proceedings are independent from tax proceedings: the presumptions that satisfy the tax authority do not satisfy a criminal judge, but a taxable base “settled” through a settlement agreement still weighs, because it fixes a figure the taxpayer has accepted.

This is why, before settling, the notice must be read through criminal-law eyes too: if the office characterises costs as non-existent or alleges an interposition, accepting may cost more than appealing. Conversely, full payment of the debt before the trial extinguishes the offences of unpaid VAT and non-fraudulent undue offsetting and mitigates the others: this too must be weighed. Thresholds and penalties are explained in our guide on tax crimes in Italy; from 1 January 2027 the matter moves into the consolidated Tax Penalties Code (Legislative Decree 173/2024).

The Taxpayer’s Ombudsman and tax collection

When the problem is not the notice but the office’s conduct (delays, repeated requests, unanswered letters, inspections that overrun their limits) there is the Garante nazionale del contribuente, the national Taxpayer’s Ombudsman, a single-person body since 2024, which does not annul notices but can trigger self-review and report dysfunctions (the guide is in Italian). On the collection side, the payment demand and the enforceable notice can be paid in instalments, today up to 84 for debts within 120,000 euros on simple request, and precautionary measures such as vehicle seizure and tax liens have precise rules and limits beyond which they must be challenged.

A real case: the VAT refund denied for a late return

In October 2026 the first-instance tax court of Pescara upheld the appeal of a Spanish company registered for VAT in Italy: the Agency had denied the refund of the VAT credit because the annual return had been filed more than 90 days late and was therefore treated as omitted.

The court held that the credit arises from the transactions, not from the return, and that if the invoices, the customs declaration and the VAT ledgers prove the substance the refund is due, ordering the Agency to pay costs. The case, with the full judgment in anonymised form, is told in the guide on late VAT returns and VAT refunds in Italy: it is the example of a denial that was formally correct but substantively unfounded, and worth challenging.

Frequently asked questions on tax litigation in Italy

Can I handle tax litigation in Italy on my own?

Yes, if the value of the dispute (tax in dispute, excluding penalties and interest) does not exceed 3,000 euros. Above that threshold a licensed defender is required. Even below the threshold, however, the procedure is electronic and formal: an appeal without grounds, or wrongly served, is inadmissible. Foreign companies normally act through their Italian fiscal representative or adviser.

If I appeal, do I have to pay in the meantime?

In part. For income taxes and VAT the Agency may enrol one third of the assessed taxes for collection while the first instance is pending, two thirds after an unfavourable judgment and the rest after the appeal. You can ask the court to suspend the notice if payment would cause serious and irreparable harm, and you can pay the part due in instalments.

Does a settlement request make me lose the right to appeal?

No. The request suspends the deadline for 90 days; if the negotiation fails or does not take place, the appeal can be served within the remaining period. Signing the settlement deed, on the other hand, closes the matter: the notice can no longer be challenged.

How long does tax litigation in Italy take?

The first instance takes on average one to two years, the appeal about the same; the Supreme Court, in 2025, 52 months on average. A suspension of the notice, if granted, arrives within a few weeks. Conciliation can close the dispute in a few months.

What happens if I lose?

You pay the assessed amount, with interest, and as a rule the other side’s legal costs, as assessed by the judge. You can appeal within 60 days of service of the judgment. Penalties remain those of the notice, unless conciliation on appeal, which reduces them to 50%.

What are the levels of judgment in Italian tax litigation?

Three: the first-instance tax court (provincial), the second-instance tax court (regional) for appeals and the Supreme Court, which decides only points of law. The former provincial and regional tax commissions were renamed Corti di giustizia tributaria by the 2022 reform of tax litigation (Law 130/2022), which also introduced professional tax judges.

What does art. 21 of Legislative Decree 546/1992 provide?

It sets the deadline for filing an appeal: 60 days from service of the challenged act, on pain of inadmissibility; for refunds, the appeal against the office’s silence may be filed 90 days after the request and until the right is time-barred. From 1 January 2027 the same rule is found in art. 67 of the consolidated Tax Justice Code.

What is new for tax litigation in Italy in 2026 and 2027?

In 2026 Legislative Decree 546/1992 remains in force together with the 2022-2024 reforms: single judge up to 5,000 euros, written witness evidence, burden of proof on the office, conciliation proposed by the judge, end of complaint and mediation, remote hearings and simplified judgments. From 1 January 2027 the consolidated Tax Justice Code (Legislative Decree 175/2024), which reorganises those rules without changing them, and the consolidated Tax Penalties Code (Legislative Decree 173/2024) enter into force: the legal references change, not the deadlines or the reductions.

Where can I find the judgments of the Italian tax courts?

In the tax case-law database of the Department of Tax Justice of the Ministry of Economy and Finance, free and searchable by keyword, court and year, as well as in professional databases. The Department’s portal also publishes a guide to the tax process and annual statistics on litigation.

Sources

In tax litigation in Italy a notice from the Agenzia delle Entrate is a proposal, not a judgment. Reading it calmly, dating the deadlines, assessing the merits also under criminal law and choosing the right tool, from voluntary disclosure to appeal, is almost always cheaper than paying out of fear or ignoring it.

Received a notice?

We tell you within days whether to negotiate, request cancellation or appeal

Studio Savia handles tax litigation in Italy from the preliminary hearing to the Supreme Court, for companies, professionals and foreign businesses with an Italian tax position. Send us the notice: the first assessment is free.

Send the notice →

Prefer to talk it through? Call the firm on +39 011 349 0809 (Mon–Fri 8:30 am–1:00 pm / 2:00–5:30 pm CET) or message us on WhatsApp.