Many foreign businesses enter the Italian market without opening a branch: a sales representative who looks after customers, an agent, a few employees working from home, a warehouse run by a logistics provider. It is a cautious way to start, but each of these footprints raises a precise question: does the foreign company risk a permanent establishment in Italy? If the answer is yes, part of its profit becomes taxable in Italy and its VAT obligations change as well.
In this case study (names and figures are fictitious, but the situation is typical) we follow a Swiss company and a Dubai company operating in Italy through staff and logistics. We look at order management, commercial contacts, personnel and the availability of premises, keeping apart two analyses that are often confused: the one for direct taxes and the one for VAT.
In brief
- For direct taxes, a permanent establishment is assessed under article 162 of the Italian Income Tax Code (TUIR) and under the applicable tax treaty, if more favourable.
- For VAT the concept is autonomous: what matters is a permanent structure with its own human and technical resources (article 11 of EU Regulation 282/2011).
- A person who negotiates and closes orders in Italy can create a permanent establishment even without an office.
- A warehouse run by a third party for storage and delivery only is normally an auxiliary activity; it becomes risky if the company’s own staff work there or if it performs core functions.
- For a Dubai company managed from Italy, the risk of being treated as tax resident in Italy must be checked as well.
In this article
The case: a Swiss company with staff and a warehouse in Italy
Alfa SA is based in Lugano and manufactures components for food-processing machinery. Most of its customers are Italian businesses and, to serve them better, it has gradually built up this presence in Italy:
- a sales manager employed by Alfa, living in Bergamo, who works from home four days out of five, visits customers, agrees prices and discounts within a price list and enters orders into the Swiss ERP system, where they are confirmed automatically;
- a technician, also an employee, who handles installation and after-sales support;
- a multi-firm agent in central Italy who introduces customers and forwards requests for quotes;
- a dedicated area in a logistics provider’s warehouse near Novara, where the technician configures and tests components before delivery;
- a meeting room in a Milan coworking space, booked by the hour to meet customers.
Invoices are issued from Switzerland and the director never sets foot in Italy. The owner is convinced that, without an Italian office, Alfa has nothing to declare in Italy apart from VAT on the goods. Is that right?
Two different analyses: direct taxes and VAT
The words are the same, the rules are not. For direct taxes, the permanent establishment determines whether Italy may tax part of the foreign company’s profit: the definition is in article 162 TUIR, modelled on article 5 of the OECD Model, and a double tax treaty prevails where it is more favourable to the taxpayer (article 169 TUIR).
For VAT, the fixed establishment determines where a transaction takes place and who must charge the tax. The definition is in article 11 of EU Implementing Regulation 282/2011 and has been shaped by the Court of Justice of the European Union independently of tax treaties. The two analyses may reach the same result, but not always, so they must be carried out separately.

The four areas to examine
Order management
This is often the decisive factor. You need to know who receives orders in Italy, who sets price and terms, and whether the head office really checks them or simply rubber-stamps them. An order that the Italian representative agrees with the customer and that the foreign ERP system confirms without any substantive review is, in substance, a contract concluded in Italy.
Commercial contacts and agents
Finding customers, presenting products and collecting requests for quotes do not by themselves create a permanent establishment. The risk arises when the person acting in Italy habitually plays the principal role leading to the conclusion of contracts. Independence also matters: an agent with several principals, an organisation of their own and their own business risk is normally independent; someone who works exclusively or almost exclusively for one company, or for closely related companies, is not.
Staff in Italy
Employees, long-term contractors and directors present in Italy are the first thing the tax authorities look at. The update to the OECD Commentary published on 19 November 2025 gave clearer criteria for home working: if a person works from home in another State for less than 50% of their total working time over a 12-month period, the home is generally not a place of business of the company; above that threshold, you need to check whether there is a commercial reason, such as meeting local customers or suppliers. The employee’s convenience is not a commercial reason.
Availability of premises
A fixed place of business does not require a lease in the company’s name: it is enough for a place to be at its disposal on a stable basis. A reserved area in a warehouse, an office regularly used at a customer’s site or an employee’s home can meet this test. A room booked by the hour in a coworking space and used occasionally usually does not.
Direct taxes: how article 162 TUIR applies
Fixed place of business and auxiliary activities
Article 162 TUIR defines a permanent establishment as a fixed place of business through which the foreign company carries on all or part of its business in Italy. Paragraph 4 excludes certain situations, including the use of facilities solely for the storage, display or delivery of the company’s goods, but since the 2018 Budget Law (Law 205/2017) the exclusion applies only if the activity is preparatory or auxiliary. A warehouse that is central to the business model, or where work is done on the product, may fall outside the exclusion.
Paragraph 5 adds an anti-fragmentation rule: complementary functions cannot be split between several sites, or between closely related companies, to make each of them look auxiliary.
The agent acting on behalf of the company
Even without a fixed place, paragraph 6 treats as a permanent establishment a person who, in Italy and on behalf of the foreign company, habitually concludes contracts or habitually plays the principal role leading to their conclusion, where the contracts are then concluded without material modification by the company. No formal power of attorney is needed: the actual role is what counts. In the well-known Philip Morris case of 2002, the Italian Supreme Court already gave weight to actual participation in negotiations rather than to powers on paper.
The role of the Italy–Switzerland treaty
The 1976 Italy–Switzerland treaty, like the 1995 treaty with the United Arab Emirates, follows the wording of article 5 of the OECD Model before the BEPS project: for a dependent agent it essentially requires an authority to conclude contracts in the name of the company, habitually exercised. Where the treaty is more favourable than the TUIR it prevails, but the version in force for the relevant year must be checked. In any case, a permanent establishment claim based on a de facto office or on a representative who closes orders remains possible under the treaty.
VAT: when there is a fixed establishment
Own human and technical resources
For VAT, a fixed establishment is a structure with a sufficient degree of permanence and suitable human and technical resources to receive and use services (a “passive” fixed establishment) or to make the company’s supplies (an “active” one). Holding an Italian VAT number is not enough on its own (article 11(3) of Regulation 282/2011): a foreign company can therefore be registered for VAT in Italy, directly or through a fiscal representative, without having a fixed establishment.
What the EU Court of Justice says
The Court has defined the boundaries of the concept several times. In Welmory (C-605/12, 2014) and Dong Yang (C-547/18, 2020) it held that a subsidiary or a service provider does not automatically become a fixed establishment of the foreign customer. In Titanium (C-931/19, 2021) it ruled that a let property without its own staff is not a fixed establishment. In Berlin Chemie (C-333/20, 2022) it confirmed that another company’s resources count only if they are available to the business as if they were its own, and that promotional activities not involved in the sale are not enough.
Why the difference matters in practice
If Alfa has no VAT fixed establishment, its sales to Italian businesses of goods already located in Italy are subject to the reverse charge: the Italian customer accounts for the tax (article 17(2) of Presidential Decree 633/1972), even if Alfa holds an Italian VAT number for imports and warehousing. If instead a fixed establishment exists and takes part in the sales, it must invoice with Italian VAT, keep the VAT books and receive invoices with VAT for services bought in Italy, such as logistics and commissions.
Comparing the two analyses in Alfa’s case
Applying both analyses to the facts of the case gives this picture:
| Factor | Direct taxes | VAT |
|---|---|---|
| Sales manager who agrees prices and enters orders that are confirmed automatically | High risk: agent playing the principal role in concluding contracts without material modification | Permanent human resource involved in sales: strong indicator |
| Home working four days out of five, with customer visits | Over 50% of working time with a commercial reason: the home may be a fixed place of business | Strengthens the permanence of the structure in Italy |
| Dedicated warehouse area with configuration and testing | Not just storage or delivery: the auxiliary exclusion is doubtful | Technical resource at the company’s disposal, used by its own staff |
| Multi-firm agent introducing customers | Normally an independent agent: low risk | Not one of Alfa’s own resources |
| Meeting room booked by the hour | No stable availability | Not relevant |
For Alfa the risk is high on both fronts, but for different reasons. For direct taxes, the sales manager’s role and the warehouse area weigh most; for VAT, it is the combination of staff and equipment used in Italy on a stable basis for sales. The consequences of an undeclared permanent establishment are corporate income tax (IRES) and regional tax (IRAP) on the attributable profit, penalties for failure to file and, above certain thresholds, possible criminal exposure.
The two results can also diverge. A dependent agent who closes contracts from their own home, without the company’s equipment, may be enough for a permanent establishment for direct taxes but not for a VAT structure. Conversely, a third-party warehouse with no company staff normally creates neither a permanent establishment nor a VAT fixed establishment, but still requires an Italian VAT registration for sales of goods located there, as we saw in the case of a foreign company with a warehouse in Italy and OSS.
The Dubai variant: an FZ-LLC managed from Italy
Beta FZ-LLC is incorporated in a Dubai free zone and sells cosmetics online to European consumers. Its founder lives in Italy for most of the year; two Italian self-employed contractors work only for Beta, run customer service, approve returns and place replenishment orders; the goods are held in an e-commerce warehouse in Lombardy.
- Permanent establishment: the contractors work exclusively for Beta and decide on orders and returns, so they are hardly independent agents. The warehouse is the core of the sales logistics, not a mere ancillary storage facility.
- Corporate residence: this is the biggest risk. Following the changes made by Legislative Decree 209/2023, article 73 TUIR treats a company as resident in Italy if, for most of the tax year, it has its registered office, its place of effective management or its day-to-day management mainly in Italy. If strategic decisions and daily management come from Italy, the whole company can be treated as Italian, not just a permanent establishment of it. We covered this in our guide on hidden permanent establishment in Italy.
- Italy–UAE treaty: it resolves dual residence on the basis of the place of effective management, so it does not protect a company that is in fact run from Italy.
- Italian shareholder: if the founder is resident in Italy, the controlled foreign company rules (article 167 TUIR) must also be considered, taking into account the UAE corporate tax introduced in 2023.
- VAT: sales from the Italian warehouse require an Italian VAT registration in any case, which for a non-EU business normally means appointing a fiscal representative.
Permanent establishment in Italy: preliminary questions
Before placing people or goods in Italy, or once the presence is already in place, it is worth answering these questions in writing:
- Who in Italy negotiates prices, discounts and terms with customers?
- Are orders collected in Italy really reviewed abroad, or confirmed automatically?
- Do the Italian representatives work only for our company or our group?
- How many days do they work from home or at customers’ premises, and for what commercial reason?
- Do we have offices, warehouse areas, equipment or vehicles at our disposal in Italy on a stable basis?
- Does the warehouse only store and deliver goods, or does it also process, assemble, test or service them?
- Are there group companies in Italy performing functions complementary to ours?
- Where do the directors meet and where are the key decisions taken?
- Are invoices from Italian service providers addressed to the foreign head office or to an Italian structure?
- Do contracts, powers of attorney and emails describe roles consistently with what actually happens?
How to reduce the risk or regularise
There is no single answer: the choice depends on how much the Italian business is expected to grow. The most common routes are:
- realigning roles and powers: genuine approval of orders at the foreign head office, price lists and terms set outside Italy, contracts with truly independent agents;
- limiting the warehouse to logistics: storage and delivery entrusted to a third-party provider, without dedicated areas run by the company’s own staff;
- opening a representative office when the Italian activity is genuinely limited to promotion or support;
- registering a permanent establishment, with an Italian tax code, VAT number and accounts, when the presence is substantial: tax is paid on the attributable profit, but assessments and penalties are avoided;
- setting up an Italian group company remunerated at arm’s length for its functions, with documented transfer pricing.
If the presence has existed for years, past periods should be reviewed before changing anything: a reorganisation does not erase tax years that are still open to assessment. For a similar case, with a property instead of staff, see our case study on property in Italy and permanent establishment; if you are considering a Swiss structure, our guide to opening a company in Switzerland may also help.
Frequently asked questions
Does an employee working from home in Italy create a permanent establishment?
Not necessarily. Under the OECD Commentary as updated in 2025, below 50% of working time over 12 months the home is generally not a place of business of the company. Above that threshold, what matters is whether there is a commercial reason, such as serving local customers, and the employee’s role in concluding contracts must always be checked too.
Does an Italian commercial agent create a permanent establishment?
If the agent is independent and acts in the ordinary course of their business, generally not. The risk arises if they work exclusively or almost exclusively for the foreign company and habitually conclude contracts, or play the principal role in doing so, without the company materially changing them.
Is a logistics warehouse in Italy a permanent establishment?
A warehouse run by a third party solely for the storage and delivery of goods normally qualifies as an auxiliary activity. The assessment changes if the company has an area permanently at its disposal, if its own staff work there or if the warehouse performs core business functions.
What happens if a foreign company operates in Italy through an undeclared permanent establishment?
The Italian Revenue Agency can assess IRES and IRAP on the profit attributable to the permanent establishment, with penalties for failure to file and interest. Above certain thresholds, failure to file can also be a criminal offence. The VAT consequences must be assessed separately.
Does an Italian VAT number mean having a permanent establishment?
No. A VAT number, obtained by direct registration or through a fiscal representative, is used to meet VAT obligations in Italy. EU Regulation 282/2011 states that a VAT number alone is not sufficient to show that a fixed establishment exists.
Are the rules different for a Swiss or a Dubai company?
The TUIR is the same, but the applicable treaty differs. For a Swiss company, the 1976 treaty may be more favourable on dependent agents. For a Dubai company, the most sensitive point is often residence: if it is managed from Italy, it may be treated as fully resident in Italy.
Sources
- Article 162 TUIR – Permanent establishment (Italian)
- Council Implementing Regulation (EU) No 282/2011 – EUR-Lex
- EU Court of Justice, case C-547/18 Dong Yang (Italian summary)
- EY – OECD 2025 Update: new rules on permanent establishment for remote work
- Italian Ministry of Economy and Finance – Double tax treaties
Alfa’s case shows how a permanent establishment often arises from small operational choices, made to serve Italian customers better, rather than from a formal decision. That is why the review should be carried out at the outset and repeated whenever roles, people or logistics change, keeping the direct tax and VAT analyses separate.
Permanent establishment in Italy
Do you have staff or goods in Italy? Let’s review your position
We analyse the roles, contracts, logistics and VAT flows of your foreign company, assess the permanent establishment risk and propose the most suitable structure for operating in Italy.
Prefer to talk it through? Call the firm on +39 011 349 0809 (Mon–Fri 8:30 am–1:00 pm / 2:00–5:30 pm CET) or message us on WhatsApp.
