Tax Court Conciliation in Italy: How It Works and How Much You Save

Tax court conciliation lets a taxpayer and the tax office settle a dispute that has already reached litigation, with a significant reduction in penalties compared to losing the case in full. Since 2024 the tool has also become more accessible, thanks to a new form that lets the judge itself propose an agreement. Here is how it works and how much you can save.

The two forms of conciliation

Tax court conciliation can take place out of hearing (the parties file a joint proposal before the hearing, which the judge then ratifies) or in hearing (the agreement is reached and recorded directly during the hearing itself). Both forms are available at any stage of the proceedings, from first instance up to the Supreme Court, until the case is decided.

How much you save on penalties

Conciliation reduces administrative penalties to 40% of the statutory minimum if reached in first instance, 50% in appeal, and — since 5 January 2024 — 60% if reached before the Supreme Court. These reductions apply on top of any agreement reached on the tax amount itself, making conciliation one of the most cost-effective ways to close a dispute once litigation has already begun.

How and when payment is made

The first instalment must be paid within 20 days of the conciliation agreement. Payment can be made in a single instalment or in up to 8 quarterly instalments (16 instalments if the amount due exceeds €50,000). Missing a payment deadline can affect the validity of the whole agreement, so instalment plans should only be chosen when genuinely sustainable.

The novelty: conciliation proposed by the judge

Since the abolition of reclamo and mediation, art. 48-bis.1 of Legislative Decree 546/1992 has given the judge itself the power to propose a conciliation to both parties, typically at the first hearing, based on the facts and evidence already on file. This mechanism now largely fills the gap left by the old reclamo and mediation procedure — see our guide on what changed with the 2024 reform for the full picture.

When conciliation is worth considering

Conciliation is generally worth exploring whenever the outcome of litigation is genuinely uncertain, or when the cost and time of a full trial outweigh a reasonable compromise. If you would rather resolve the matter before reaching court, assessment with agreement and autotutela remain available earlier in the process, and if you simply need more time to pay an amount you agree with, instalment payment is a separate option. Our guide to tax court appeals covers the litigation process itself in more detail.

Source: Ministry of Economy and Finance, Tax Justice Department (dgt.mef.gov.it).

Free Initial Assessment

Do you have a similar situation?

Describe your situation below: we’ll tell you right away how to proceed. If you already have useful documents, you can simply send them to us by replying to our confirmation email.

Richiesta Generica (EN)

Prefer to talk it through? Call the firm on +39 011 349 0809 (Mon–Fri 8:30 am–1:00 pm / 2:00–5:30 pm CET) or message us on WhatsApp.