Some people still search for “reclamo and mediation” when facing a dispute with the Italian tax authorities, remembering an institution that, until recently, was a mandatory step before bringing a case to a judge. Let’s be clear from the start: reclamo and mediation no longer exist. The institution was abolished by Legislative Decree 220/2023, effective for appeals notified from 4 January 2024 onwards. Here is how it used to work, why it was eliminated, and — most importantly — what has taken its place today.
What reclamo and mediation used to be
Introduced by art. 17-bis of Legislative Decree 546/1992, the institution required that, for disputes up to €50,000, a taxpayer file a reclamo (which could also include a mediation proposal) with the issuing tax office before lodging an actual appeal. Only after 90 days without a resolution, or in case of an explicit rejection, could the taxpayer proceed before what is today called the Tax Court of First Instance. If the mediation ended with an agreement, administrative penalties were reduced to 35% of the statutory minimum.
Why it was abolished
The reform of tax justice (Law 130/2022 and, in its implementing decree, Legislative Decree 220/2023) redesigned much of the tax process. Reclamo and mediation had come to be seen as an ineffective extra step: in practice, most reclami ended up in court anyway, lengthening the timeline without any real deflationary benefit. The legislator therefore chose to abolish it, under art. 2 comma 3 letter a) of Legislative Decree 220/2023, for all appeals notified from 4 January 2024 onwards. Appeals notified before that date remain subject to the old rules.
What replaced it: conciliation proposed by the judge
In place of reclamo and mediation, the reform strengthened a different tool: judicial conciliation under art. 48-bis.1 of Legislative Decree 546/1992, which now allows the judge itself to propose a conciliation between the parties during the proceedings, at the first hearing or beforehand. We look at how this works, and how much it can save on penalties, in our dedicated guide on tax court conciliation.
What to do today if you have a dispute with the tax authorities
Without reclamo and mediation as a mandatory filter, the available paths today depend on the stage of the dispute. If you have just received an automated notice, an avviso bonario can often be settled without going to court. If a formal assessment has already been issued, accertamento con adesione (assessment with agreement) lets you negotiate directly with the tax office before any appeal. If you believe the office made a clear error, an autotutela request can have the act corrected or cancelled. And if the case does go before a judge, conciliation remains available at any stage, with penalty reductions of up to 60%. A tax and legal advisor can help you evaluate which path fits your specific situation and its statutory deadlines.
Source: fiscomania.com.
Free Initial Assessment
Do you have a similar situation?
Describe your situation below: we’ll tell you right away how to proceed. If you already have useful documents, you can simply send them to us by replying to our confirmation email.
Prefer to talk it through? Call the firm on +39 011 349 0809 (Mon–Fri 8:30 am–1:00 pm / 2:00–5:30 pm CET) or message us on WhatsApp.
