The pre-assessment hearing (contraddittorio preventivo) is the stage in which the Italian Revenue Agency, before issuing a tax assessment notice, sends the taxpayer a draft assessment (schema di atto) and grants 60 days to respond. It is mandatory for most acts issued since 30 April 2024 and it is the best moment to close or reduce a dispute: afterwards, the options narrow.
This guide explains what the draft assessment contains, which deadlines really matter, how to prepare written observations and when it is better to request a settlement agreement instead.
In brief
- The pre-assessment hearing is governed by Article 6-bis of the Taxpayers’ Bill of Rights (Law 212/2000), introduced by Legislative Decree 219/2023.
- The draft assessment sets out findings, reasons and amounts: you have 60 days to file observations and request a copy of the file.
- Within 30 days of the draft you can request a settlement agreement (accertamento con adesione), with penalties reduced to one third of the minimum.
- The final act must explain why the observations were rejected; if the required hearing is missing, the act can be annulled.
- If you do not request the settlement after the draft, only a 15-day window remains after the final notice: decisions are best made early.
Table of contents
What the pre-assessment hearing is and when it applies
Article 6-bis of Law 212/2000 provides that acts which can be challenged before the tax courts must be preceded, on pain of annulment, by an informed and effective hearing. The rule applies to acts issued from 30 April 2024, even when they concern earlier tax years.
Automated or substantially automated acts, quick-settlement acts, the outcome of formal checks on tax returns and cases of well-founded risk to collection are excluded. A Ministry of Economy decree of 24 April 2024 lists the excluded acts in detail. For an overview of the Agency’s powers, see our guide on tax assessment powers in Italy.
What the draft assessment contains
The draft assessment is, in practice, a preview of the assessment notice. It usually contains:
- the findings, i.e. the violations alleged year by year and tax by tax;
- the reasoning and evidence behind the claim (audit reports, bank data, third-party documents, mark-up percentages);
- the calculation of additional taxes, penalties and interest;
- the invitation to file observations within 60 days and to inspect the file;
- the invitation to consider a settlement agreement.
If a tax audit report (PVC) was issued after an inspection, the draft assessment usually repeats its findings. After the reform this step replaced the former 60-day period after the audit report under Article 12(7) of the Taxpayers’ Bill of Rights.
Deadlines in the pre-assessment hearing
| Step | Deadline | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Observations | 60 days from the draft | The office cannot issue the act before this deadline |
| Access to the file | Within the 60 days | You can inspect and copy the documents behind the claim |
| Request for a settlement agreement | 30 days from the draft | The office invites you to a meeting to discuss an agreement |
| Office’s limitation period | Extension up to 120 days | If the limitation period expires close to the hearing, it is extended |
| Final act | After the 60 days | Must give reasons for rejecting the observations |
Dates run from service of the draft, usually by certified e-mail (PEC) or registered letter. Keep the receipt: it is the reference for every later deadline.
How to prepare observations
Observations are a technical document, not a letter of complaint. They work when every finding is answered with facts and documents. The method we use:
- read the draft finding by finding and separate factual issues from legal ones;
- request a copy of the file at once, to see all the evidence gathered, not only what is quoted;
- check procedural defects: competence, limitation periods, reasoning, lawfulness of evidence (for example the authorisation for bank investigations);
- rebuild the figures: tax and penalty calculations often contain errors or duplications;
- attach numbered documentary evidence referred to in the text (contracts, invoices, bank statements, expert reports);
- where possible, propose a credible alternative reconstruction, not just a denial;
- send the document by certified e-mail within the 60 days and keep the receipts.
What to avoid in observations
Avoid unsupported statements, unnecessary admissions and arguments that contradict each other. Whatever you write becomes part of the file and may be read by the judge in a later tax appeal: observations should be built with the next stage already in mind.
Observations or settlement agreement?
The two paths are not mutually exclusive: you can file observations and, if the conditions arise, still open settlement talks. The choice depends on how solid the findings are and on the amount.
| Observations | Settlement agreement | |
|---|---|---|
| Goal | Dismissal or reduction of findings | Close with an agreement on the amounts |
| Deadline | 60 days | Request within 30 days of the draft |
| Penalties | In full, if the act is issued | Reduced to one third of the minimum |
| Payment | None, unless a final act follows | Lump sum or up to 8 quarterly instalments (16 above EUR 50,000) |
| When it makes sense | Weak findings or clear defects | Partly founded findings, interest in closing |
Conditions and calculations are covered in our guide to the tax settlement agreement in Italy.
What happens after the pre-assessment hearing
Once the 60 days have passed, the office may drop the case, reduce the findings or issue the assessment notice. The final act must take the observations into account and give specific reasons for those it rejects. If the notice contains new allegations compared with the draft, or ignores the defence filed, the defect must be raised in an appeal within 60 days of service.
We have commented on a recent judgment on the relationship between draft and final act: draft assessment different from the final notice.
Most common mistakes
- letting the 60 days lapse in the belief that the defence can wait;
- not requesting the file and answering only what the draft says;
- missing the 30 days for a settlement when an agreement would have paid off;
- sending documents in no order or not linked to individual findings;
- handling claims based on bank accounts or complex presumptions without assistance.
Frequently asked questions
Is the pre-assessment hearing always mandatory?
No. It is mandatory for appealable acts issued from 30 April 2024, with the exclusions set by Article 6-bis and the ministerial decree of 24 April 2024: automated acts, quick settlement, formal checks and cases of risk to collection.
What happens if I do not answer the draft assessment?
Once the 60 days have passed, the office can issue the assessment notice based on the draft. Not answering is not a violation, but it is a lost chance to reduce or close the claim.
Can I ask for more time to file observations?
The 60-day period is set by law. If you are waiting for third-party documents, file observations within the deadline anyway and state that they will be supplemented.
What if the office skips the hearing?
An act issued without the required hearing can be annulled. The defect, however, must be raised in an appeal: if the act is not challenged, it becomes final.
Do I need a professional for the hearing?
It is not compulsory, but it is advisable: observations shape the final act and any later litigation. A chartered accountant experienced in tax disputes can assess findings, evidence and whether a settlement makes sense.
Sources
- Article 6-bis, Law 212 of 27 July 2000 (Taxpayers’ Bill of Rights), introduced by Legislative Decree 219 of 30 December 2023
- Decree of the Minister of Economy and Finance of 24 April 2024 (acts excluded from the hearing)
- Article 6(2-bis) and (2-ter), Legislative Decree 218 of 19 June 1997, as amended by Legislative Decree 13 of 12 February 2024
- Articles 7-bis and 12, Law 212/2000
- Consolidated legislation (in Italian): Normattiva; official rulings, circulars and forms: Agenzia delle Entrate
The pre-assessment hearing is the first real opportunity to defend yourself and often the most effective one. If you have received a draft assessment, have it read straight away: the 30 days for a settlement go by quickly.
Studio Savia · Tax assessment defence
Have you received a draft assessment?
Send us the document: the first reading is free and we reply within 2 working days with an initial assessment.
Request a first readingPrefer to talk it through? Call the firm on +39 011 349 0809 (Mon–Fri 8:30 am–1:00 pm / 2:00–5:30 pm CET) or message us on WhatsApp.
