Bank investigations without prior authorisation: under Cassazione order 19956/2026 the data cannot be used

Bank investigations are the most effective tool available to the Italian Revenue Agency (Agenzia delle Entrate) and the Guardia di Finanza: every unexplained deposit into a bank account can become undeclared income, and the taxpayer must prove otherwise, transaction by transaction. By law, however, access to the accounts requires a prior authorisation from the regional or central director (or from the regional commander for the Guardia di Finanza). For years the Italian Supreme Court (Corte di Cassazione) treated this authorisation as an internal act whose absence did not make the data unusable.

With order no. 19956 of 15 June 2026 the Court changed course: the authorisation must exist before the bank investigations begin and must have a minimum, verifiable content, otherwise the bank data cannot support the assessment. This guide explains the case, the principle, the link with the judgment of the European Court of Human Rights against Italy and what to do in practice if you receive an assessment based on bank account movements, including if you are a foreign resident or company with accounts in Italy.

In brief

  • A professional partnership had received IRPEF, IRAP and VAT assessments for 2005 and 2006, based on unexplained deposits that emerged from bank investigations. The taxpayers argued that the authorisation to access the accounts had been issued after the assessment and in any case had never been filed in court.
  • The Cassazione, with order no. 19956/2026 (and the twin order no. 19960/2026), held that the authorisation remains an internal preparatory act, but it must pre-exist the investigations and have a minimum content that makes it possible to verify, even afterwards, the grounds, the object and the limits of the access to the accounts.
  • If the authorisation is missing or inadequate and the taxpayer raises the point specifically and in time, the bank data cannot be used and the assessment is invalid for the part based on them. The court cannot raise the defect of its own motion.
  • The turnaround adopts the judgment of the European Court of Human Rights in Ferrieri and Bonassisa v. Italy of 8 January 2026, which found a systemic violation of Article 8 of the Convention (respect for private life) in the Italian rules on financial investigations.
  • Since 2024, Article 7-quater of the Italian Taxpayers’ Charter (Statuto del contribuente) states that evidence obtained in breach of the law cannot be used: the new reading of the authorisation fits with this rule and strengthens the taxpayer’s defence.

How bank investigations work in an Italian tax assessment

Bank investigations are governed by Article 32, paragraph 1, no. 7, of Presidential Decree 600/1973 for income taxes and by Article 51, paragraph 2, no. 7, of Presidential Decree 633/1972 for VAT. The tax office can ask banks, Poste Italiane and financial intermediaries for details of the relationships held by the taxpayer and the transactions carried out, including joint accounts and, under certain conditions, accounts of family members and shareholders. Requests are now made electronically and cross-checked with the Register of financial relationships (Archivio dei rapporti finanziari), which makes bank investigations fast and cheap for the administration.

The strength of the tool lies in the legal presumption set out in the same provision. Unexplained deposits are deemed to be revenue or fees, while unexplained withdrawals are presumed to be revenue only for businesses and only above 1,000 euro per day and 5,000 euro per month (thresholds introduced by Decree-Law 193/2016). For self-employed professionals the presumption on withdrawals was struck down by the Constitutional Court in judgment no. 228/2014.

It is a rebuttable legal presumption: the office does not need further evidence, and it is the taxpayer who must show, with analytical evidence, that each transaction is not income, for example because it is a transfer between own accounts, a loan, a gift or money already taxed. For an overview of the investigative powers of the administration see our guide on tax assessment powers in Italy.

Precisely because the presumption is so strong, the law imposes a filter upstream: bank investigations can be started only with the prior authorisation of the central director for assessments or the regional director of the Revenue Agency or, for the Guardia di Finanza, of the regional commander. The question decided by the Cassazione in 2026 is what happens when this filter does not work.

The case: bank investigations into a professional partnership and a late authorisation

The case concerns a professional partnership and its members, who received assessments for IRPEF, IRAP and VAT for 2005 and 2006. The assessments were built on deposits that emerged from the bank investigations and that the taxpayers had not explained. In their appeal the professionals challenged, among other things, the lawfulness of the access to the accounts: according to their reconstruction the authorisation had been issued about two years after the assessment, and the office had never filed it in court. In the case decided by twin order no. 19960/2026 the authorisation was mentioned in the assessment but not attached.

The lower tax courts had rejected the objection by applying the case law then prevailing: the authorisation is an internal act of the administration, it need not state reasons or be attached, and its absence does not make the data unusable unless the taxpayer suffers actual prejudice. This was the line followed for years by the Tax Section in numerous decisions, including Cass. 9480/2018, 13353/2018, 3242/2021, 10576/2022, 4853/2024 and 27128/2025.

What the Cassazione decided on bank investigations in order 19956/2026

The Court upheld the taxpayers’ appeal and referred the case back to the lower court. The reasoning reverses the previous approach on four points.

The authorisation must come before the investigations

The authorisation remains an internal preparatory act, but it must pre-exist the bank investigations. An authorisation issued after access to the accounts, or even after the assessment, is not a mere formal irregularity: it means that the interference with the taxpayer’s private life took place without the control required by law. What should have filtered access from the start cannot be cured afterwards.

A minimum, verifiable content is required

A pre-printed form signed by the manager is not enough. The authorisation must have a minimum content that makes it possible to verify, even ex post, the grounds, the object and the limits of the interference: why the investigation is carried out, on which accounts, for which periods. The Court clarifies, however, that a statement of reasons in the technical sense of Law 241/1990 or Article 7 of the Taxpayers’ Charter is not required: the check concerns whether a real assessment took place, not the quality of the reasoning.

Without a valid authorisation the data cannot be used

If the authorisation is missing or lacks the minimum content, the bank data cannot be used and the assessment is invalid, wholly or partly, for the part based on them. This is the break with the past: whether the taxpayer suffered actual prejudice no longer matters, because the violation concerns a fundamental right and the sanction is that the evidence is unusable. The parts of the assessment based on elements other than the bank investigations remain valid, which is why the case goes back to the lower court.

The objection must be specific and timely

The court cannot raise the missing or inadequate authorisation of its own motion. The taxpayer must raise the objection specifically in the initial appeal, asking the office to file the authorisation and challenging its date and content. A generic ground such as “all the conditions for the investigations are disputed” is not enough. Once the objection is raised, it is for the administration to prove that it had a pre-existing and adequate authorisation.

Why the Cassazione changed course: the European Court judgment

The turnaround did not come out of nowhere. In Ferrieri and Bonassisa v. Italy of 8 January 2026 the European Court of Human Rights found a violation of Article 8 of the Convention, which protects private life, in the Italian rules on financial investigations. According to the Strasbourg judges the legislation leaves excessive discretion to the administration, the authorisation cannot be challenged and is not subject to effective review, and the Taxpayers’ Ombudsman (Garante del contribuente) has no binding powers.

The Court described the problem as systemic, meaning that it lies in the law and not in the single case. The direct precedent is Italgomme Pneumatici v. Italy of 6 February 2025, which had already criticised inspections of business premises for the same reasons.

The Cassazione chose to align Italian law through interpretation, without waiting for the legislator: if the authorisation is the only safeguard provided, it must at least really exist, before access, and leave a verifiable trace. The order also refers to Articles 7, 8 and 52 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union and to the case law of the Joint Sections (Cass. SS.UU. 3182/2022) on the relationship between national law and European safeguards.

Some commentators note that the Court adopted the European judgment only in part: the control remains internal to the administration and is not entrusted to an independent third party, as Strasbourg required. According to some sources, the question may also have been referred to the Joint Sections with an interlocutory order of May 2026: pending a final ruling, order 19956/2026 is today the precedent most favourable to taxpayers on bank investigations, but the case law may still be refined.

The link with Article 7-quater of the Taxpayers’ Charter

Since 18 January 2024, following Legislative Decree 219/2023, the Taxpayers’ Charter contains an express rule on unusable evidence: Article 7-quater provides that evidence obtained after the deadlines set for tax audits or in breach of the law cannot be used for the administrative or judicial assessment of the tax. Bank investigations carried out without a valid prior authorisation are, according to the new reading of the Cassazione, evidence obtained in breach of the law.

For assessments served from 2024 onwards, the defence therefore has a double basis: the Cassazione case law aligned with the European Court and the rule of the Charter. Articles 7-bis and 7-ter of the Charter then govern voidable and null acts. The violation must still be raised in the proceedings: the court will not detect it on its own.

What to do if you receive an assessment based on bank investigations

The order changes the order of the checks to be made when an assessment arrives, or even earlier a draft assessment based on bank accounts. Before dealing with the explanation of individual transactions, it is worth checking the lawfulness of the access.

  1. Ask for the authorisation. With a request for access to the file, or during the pre-assessment hearing, ask for a copy of the authorisation to carry out bank investigations and of the request for authorisation. Note whether the office provides it, refuses or does not answer.
  2. Check the date. The authorisation must predate the requests sent to the banks. Compare its date with that of the questionnaires to the intermediaries, which appears in the tax audit report or in the investigation file.
  3. Check the content. Make sure the authorisation identifies the taxpayer, the accounts or categories of accounts, the tax years and the reasons for the investigation. A generic form with no reference to the case can be challenged because it does not allow the ex post check required by the Court.
  4. Raise the objection specifically in the appeal. In the tax appeal, expressly challenge the absence, lateness or inadequacy of the authorisation, citing order 19956/2026, the Ferrieri and Bonassisa judgment and Article 7-quater of the Charter, and ask the office to file it. The objection cannot be introduced for the first time on appeal.
  5. Prepare the analytical evidence anyway. Unusability affects only the part of the assessment based on bank data. It is therefore wise to document in parallel the nature of the movements (transfers between own accounts, shareholder loans, refunds, money already taxed, funds coming from abroad), because the office may support the assessment with other elements.
  6. Consider the alternatives. A tax settlement agreement reduces penalties but means giving up the defects of the act. If the authorisation is missing or late, the assessment changes: the defect may bring down the claim in whole or in part.

The same checks also matter for timing. Remember that the assessment cannot be issued before 60 days from the end of the tax audit: see our commentary on the assessment signed before the 60-day period. When the amount at stake exceeds the criminal thresholds, bank investigations often also feed proceedings for unfaithful tax return: see the guide on tax crimes in Italy.

AspectPrevious case lawOrder 19956/2026
Nature of the authorisationInternal act, no reasons, not attachedInternal act, but with a minimum verifiable content
Time of issueIrrelevant without actual prejudiceMust pre-exist the bank investigations
Missing or late authorisationData still usableData unusable, assessment invalid for that part
Raising the defectTaxpayer’s objectionOnly on a specific and timely objection, not of the court’s own motion
Reasons under Law 241/1990 or Art. 7 CharterNot requiredNot required
BasisCass. 9480/2018, 13353/2018, 4853/2024, 27128/2025ECtHR Ferrieri and Bonassisa 8.1.2026; Art. 8 ECHR; Arts. 7, 8, 52 EU Charter

Frequently asked questions on bank investigations and the authorisation

Does the order also apply to assessments by the Guardia di Finanza?

Yes. The law requires the authorisation of the regional commander for bank investigations carried out by the Guardia di Finanza, and the Cassazione principle concerns the authorisation as such, whoever issues it. Here too the authorisation must predate the requests to the intermediaries and have a verifiable content.

Can I rely on the defect if the proceedings are already pending?

It depends on what was written in the initial appeal. The objection must be specific and timely: if the appeal already challenged the absence or lateness of the authorisation, the new case law can be invoked at every stage. If the issue was never raised, the court cannot raise it of its own motion and introducing it on appeal is, as a rule, too late.

If the authorisation is missing, is the whole assessment cancelled?

Not necessarily. What becomes unusable is the data collected through the bank investigations; the assessment falls for the part based on those data. If the office also used other elements, such as invoices, third-party statements or sector studies, that part of the assessment remains to be examined on the merits. This is why the Cassazione referred the case back to the lower court.

Must the office attach the authorisation to the assessment?

No, attaching it is not mandatory and the authorisation does not require a formal statement of reasons. But if the taxpayer disputes its existence or content, the office must file it in court. If it does not, or if it files an act issued after the bank investigations, the data become unusable.

Can bank investigations cover family members’ accounts?

Yes, if the office shows, even through presumptions, that those accounts are in fact available to the taxpayer. The presence of family members on the accounts is a frequently used indicator. For these accounts too, however, the prior authorisation is required, and the principles of order 19956/2026 apply in the same way.

Does it apply to companies and to foreign taxpayers?

Yes. The principle concerns all bank investigations carried out under Article 32 of Presidential Decree 600/1973 and Article 51 of Presidential Decree 633/1972, so it also covers partnerships, companies and non-residents taxable in Italy with accounts held at Italian intermediaries. For businesses the presumption extends to withdrawals above the legal thresholds, and checking the authorisation is even more important. The full range of defence tools, from the pre-assessment hearing to the trial, is in our guide on tax litigation in Italy.

Sources

Bank investigations remain the most feared tool of Italian tax assessments, because the presumption leaves the taxpayer to explain every deposit. Order 19956/2026, however, introduces a check that was missing: before discussing the movements, one discusses how the office gained access to the accounts. Anyone who receives an assessment based on bank investigations should immediately ask for the authorisation, check its date and content and raise the objection in the appeal, while still preparing analytical evidence on the individual transactions.

Have you received an Italian tax assessment based on your bank account movements?

We check the authorisation and the soundness of the assessment

Studio Savia assists professionals, companies, private individuals and non-residents in assessments based on bank investigations: access to the file, check of the authorisation, pre-assessment hearing, analytical reconstruction of the movements and appeal. The initial review is free of charge.

Request a review →

Prefer to talk it through? Call the firm on +39 011 349 0809 (Mon–Fri 8:30 am–1:00 pm / 2:00–5:30 pm CET) or message us on WhatsApp.