Tax Audit Report (PVC) in Italy: Non-Challengeable Nature and Referral to the Public Prosecutor

A tax audit report (in Italian, processo verbale di constatazione or PVC) is the document in which the Guardia di Finanza or the Agenzia delle Entrate put in writing the outcome of an access, inspection or tax audit. It is not a tax assessment, it is not final, and it cannot be challenged on its own, but it is the document from which, almost always, the subsequent notice of assessment is born. Understanding how a tax audit report works, what rights the taxpayer has before it turns into a full assessment, and when its contents can reach the Public Prosecutor, is essential for anyone who receives one.

What is a tax audit report

The tax audit report, governed generally by article 24 of law 4/1929, is the document in which the auditors (Guardia di Finanza officers or Agenzia delle Entrate officials) summarize the operations carried out during an access, inspection or audit, and describe the findings: formal violations, additional taxes due, indicative elements of fraudulent conduct. The report closes the “on the ground” investigative phase, but on its own it does not produce any enforceable tax claim.

It is worth distinguishing the tax audit report from other acts with which it is often confused: the notice of assessment, which is the act with which the Agenzia delle Entrate corrects what was declared and demands payment of taxes, penalties and interest; and the payment notice (cartella esattoriale), with which Agenzia delle Entrate-Riscossione demands payment of sums already registered as due. For the broader powers the tax authorities use to build a tax assessment in the first place, see our guide on tax assessment powers in Italy.

How the tax audit report is drafted

The report is drafted at the end of the audit operations, in an adversarial exchange with the taxpayer or a delegate, who has the right to have observations and requests included in it. The document must be signed by the auditors and, if present, by the taxpayer; a copy must be delivered to them at the same time. The report contains a detailed description of the activities carried out, the findings with their legal grounds, the attachments (documents acquired, questionnaires, statements made by third parties) and an indication of the timing and manner in which the taxpayer can react.

The non-challengeable nature of the tax audit report

The tax audit report is not included in the list of acts that can be independently challenged before the tax courts, set out in article 19 of Legislative Decree 546/1992: not being a tax act itself, but a mere internal investigative act within the procedure, it does not on its own produce any immediate adverse effect for the taxpayer. The report only becomes relevant for litigation purposes once its findings are incorporated into a subsequent notice of assessment, which at that point becomes challengeable through ordinary means.

This means the taxpayer cannot file an appeal against the tax audit report as such, but must wait for the tax act that incorporates its contents (or, in some cases, act earlier through the defensive observations described in the next section).

The exception: settlement on the tax audit report

Article 5-quater of Legislative Decree 218/1997 introduces an important exception: the taxpayer can settle on the contents of the tax audit report within 30 days of its delivery, provided it concerns violations relating to more than one tax period. Settlement allows the position to be closed with reduced penalties (one-sixth of the minimum) without waiting for the notice of assessment to be issued, with clear advantages in terms of time and cost compared to litigation.

The right to a prior hearing: the taxpayer’s observations

Article 12, paragraph 7, of law 212/2000 (the Taxpayer’s Statute) grants the taxpayer the right to submit, within 60 days of receiving a copy of the tax audit report, observations and requests that the tax office must evaluate before issuing the notice of assessment. The notice cannot be issued before this term expires, except in cases of special and justified urgency.

Legislative Decree 219/2023 generalized this safeguard by introducing the new article 6-bis into the Taxpayer’s Statute, which extends the obligation of a prior hearing to all tax acts, not only those preceded by a tax audit report, thereby strengthening procedural protection for the taxpayer at every stage of the assessment.

From the tax audit report to the notice of assessment: the procedural flow

The typical path from the tax audit report to the final tax act follows these stages: drafting and delivery of the report at the end of the audit; a 60-day term for the taxpayer’s observations; evaluation of the observations by the tax office, which may accept them in whole or in part, or reject them while explaining its position; issuance of the notice of assessment, which incorporates the report’s findings (possibly revised) and becomes the act that can be independently challenged before the tax court.

As an alternative to this path, the taxpayer can choose the settlement on the tax audit report described above, or, once the notice of assessment is received, activate ordinary dispute-reduction tools such as tax acquiescence or reclamo and tax mediation.

Referral to the Public Prosecutor: the notitia criminis

When, during the audit, the auditors find elements that amount to a tax crime, the duty to report set out in article 331 of the Code of Criminal Procedure is triggered: notice of the crime (notitia criminis) must be transmitted without delay to the competent Public Prosecutor’s Office. This duty is autonomous and does not depend on the conclusion of the tax audit or on the issuance of the notice of assessment: criminal proceedings and tax proceedings generally follow parallel and independent tracks.

The criminal relevance thresholds

Not every violation found in the report becomes criminally relevant: Legislative Decree 74/2000, as most recently amended by Legislative Decree 87/2024, sets precise quantitative thresholds (of evaded tax and of active items withheld from taxation) above which conduct such as unfaithful returns, failure to file returns, concealment or destruction of accounting records and the other offences set out in the law become criminally relevant, in addition to being subject to tax penalties.

The relationship between criminal and tax proceedings

For a long time, the principle of the “double track” ensured full autonomy and independence between criminal and tax proceedings, which could even reach conflicting outcomes on the same facts. The Constitutional Court, with judgment no. 50 of 2026, partly scaled back this autonomy, requiring greater coordination between the two proceedings on specific points, in line with the need to avoid radically inconsistent assessments of the same conduct and to give effect to the ne bis in idem principle, already addressed by the European Court of Human Rights in the well-known Grande Stevens case law.

Legislative Decree 87/2024 also introduced the new article 21-bis into Legislative Decree 74/2000, which governs the effect of a final criminal acquittal on tax proceedings, a further step towards greater coordination between the two levels.

How to respond to a tax audit report

Once a tax audit report is received, it is advisable to carefully review each finding, verify the factual and legal grounds, and assess whether to submit defensive observations within the 60-day term, settle on the report’s contents when advantageous, or wait for the notice of assessment to assert one’s position through the appropriate channels. Where findings may be criminally relevant, it is essential to coordinate the tax defense with the criminal defense from the outset, given the growing interaction between the two levels.

Why rely on a commercialista for a tax audit report

Assessing the merits of the findings contained in a tax audit report, preparing effective defensive observations and choosing the most suitable strategy among settlement, prior hearing and litigation requires specific technical skills and promptness. Studio Savia supports businesses and professionals from the moment the report is delivered, to reduce tax risk and, when necessary, properly coordinate the tax and criminal tracks.

To learn more about the procedural aspects, see also the official page of the Agenzia delle Entrate dedicated to the processo verbale di constatazione.

The audit report closes the inspection: if the inspection is still under way, read the guide on how to behave during a tax inspection. After the report, the Office usually serves the draft assessment, which opens the pre-assessment hearing.

Frequently asked questions about the tax audit report in Italy

Can a tax audit report be challenged?

No, the tax audit report is not among the acts that can be independently challenged under article 19 of Legislative Decree 546/1992: it becomes contestable only once its findings flow into a notice of assessment, except in the case of settlement on the report.

How much time do I have to submit observations after a tax audit report?

Article 12, paragraph 7, of law 212/2000 grants 60 days from delivery of the report to submit observations and requests, which the tax office must evaluate before issuing the notice of assessment.

What is settlement on the tax audit report?

It is the option, under article 5-quater of Legislative Decree 218/1997, to settle on the report’s contents within 30 days, benefiting from reduced penalties without waiting for the notice of assessment.

When is a tax audit report referred to the Public Prosecutor?

When the auditors find elements that amount to a tax crime, they are required under article 331 of the Code of Criminal Procedure to transmit notice of the crime to the competent Public Prosecutor’s Office without delay.

Do criminal and tax proceedings run together?

As a rule they follow parallel and independent tracks, but Constitutional Court judgment no. 50 of 2026 required greater coordination between the two proceedings on specific points.

Tax audit report (PVC)

Been served a PVC after an audit by the Guardia di Finanza or the Revenue Agency?

Tell us what happened: we will assess the findings, the defence brief to file within 60 days and the possible settlement options.

Prima Analisi Gratuita - Aziende (EN)

Prefer to talk it through? Call the firm on +39 011 349 0809 (Mon–Fri 8:30 am–1:00 pm / 2:00–5:30 pm CET) or message us on WhatsApp.