Tax Crimes in Italy: Criminal Offences Under Legislative Decree 74/2000 and How to Avoid Criminal Exposure

Tax crimes are the conducts the Italian legislator has deemed serious enough to deserve, beyond administrative penalties, a criminal response too: fraudulent, false or omitted tax returns, or the omitted payment of taxes above certain thresholds, can amount to an actual crime under Legislative Decree 74/2000, most recently reformed in 2024. Understanding which conducts are criminally relevant, which thresholds trigger a crime, and which tools exist to avoid or reduce criminal exposure is essential for every entrepreneur and professional operating in Italy.

What is Italian tax criminal law

Italian tax criminal law is the branch of criminal law that governs crimes committed in violation of tax rules. Its main source is Legislative Decree no. 74 of 10 March 2000, which replaced the earlier system of “prodromal offences” with a framework centred on the tax return: the focus is no longer a single accounting irregularity, but the moment in which the taxpayer communicates (or fails to communicate) income and taxes due to the tax authorities. Not every tax violation has criminal relevance: only the most serious conducts, above precise quantitative thresholds, amount to a crime; the others remain sanctionable only at the administrative level.

For an overview of the powers with which the Revenue Agency and the Guardia di Finanza detect these conducts, see our guide on tax assessment powers in Italy; for the document with which such checks are concluded, see our in-depth guide on the tax audit report (PVC).

The tax crimes provided for by Legislative Decree 74/2000

The decree distinguishes two broad categories of tax crimes: return-based crimes, tied to the content of the return filed (or not filed), and collection-based crimes, tied to the failure to pay taxes already declared or to the concealment of assets from enforced collection.

If a preventive seizure has already been ordered, full payment of the amount settled through a tax settlement agreement requires it to be lifted, even if the criminal judge considers the evaded tax to be higher: see our commentary on judgment 27741/2025 on preventive seizure and tax settlements.

Return-based crimes

This category includes: fraudulent declaration through the use of invoices or other documents for non-existent transactions (art. 2), punished regardless of quantitative thresholds; fraudulent declaration through other devices (art. 3), which instead requires exceeding thresholds of evaded tax and of assets concealed from taxation; false declaration (art. 4), when the return shows lower assets or higher fictitious liabilities than the truth, above certain thresholds; failure to file a return (art. 5), when despite an obligation the taxpayer does not file any return at all; and the issuance of invoices or other documents for non-existent transactions (art. 8), the mirror conduct of whoever uses them.

Collection-based crimes

Collection-based crimes instead include: failure to pay certified withholding taxes (art. 10-bis); failure to pay VAT (art. 10-ter); undue offsetting, with non-existent or non-due tax credits (art. 10-quater); and fraudulent evasion of tax payment, when the taxpayer carries out simulated or fraudulent acts on their own assets to render enforced collection ineffective (art. 11). To these is added the concealment or destruction of accounting documents (art. 10), which prevents the reconstruction of income or turnover.

Punishment thresholds and penalties

Every offence, with the exception of fraudulent declaration through false invoices and the concealment of accounting documents in the most serious cases, sets quantitative thresholds below which the conduct remains an administrative offence only. The thresholds have been revised over time and currently range, depending on the offence, between 30,000 and 150,000 euros of evaded tax, with additional percentage thresholds for some cases. Custodial penalties range, depending on the crime, from a minimum of one year and six months up to a maximum of eight years of imprisonment for the most serious conducts, such as fraudulent declaration through false invoices for significant amounts.

Whether a threshold has been exceeded must always be verified case by case, since small differences in the amount of evaded tax or of assets concealed from taxation can shift a conduct from the administrative to the criminal sphere, with very different consequences in terms of sanctions and procedure.

Preventive seizure and confiscation, including by equivalent value

Alongside custodial penalties, Legislative Decree 74/2000 provides for mandatory confiscation of the profit or price of the crime, which can also be ordered by equivalent value when it is not possible to identify or seize the assets that directly constitute the profit of the evasion. In practice, this often translates into a preventive seizure, ordered already in the early stages of the criminal proceedings, which can affect sums of money, real estate or other assets of the taxpayer for a value corresponding to the evaded tax, even before a final conviction.

Grounds for non-punishability: extinguishing the tax debt

Article 13 of Legislative Decree 74/2000 provides for a ground of non-punishability of particular practical relevance: for the crimes of omitted payment (withholding taxes, VAT) and for undue offsetting with non-due tax credits, the crime is not punishable if the tax debt, including administrative penalties and interest, is fully extinguished by payment, even following conciliation or settlement procedures, before the opening of the first-instance trial. For false declaration and failure to file a return, extinguishing the debt through voluntary disclosure (ravvedimento operoso) or a late return, if this occurs before the offender has had formal knowledge of accesses, inspections, audits or the start of criminal proceedings, produces the same effect.

This ground of non-punishability makes it particularly worthwhile, whenever possible, to regularise one’s tax position as soon as possible: anyone who has received a tax assessment notice or a payment notice and is considering extinguishing the debt should always also consider the impact of that choice on the criminal side, in addition to the tax side. On the settlement tools available for this purpose, see our guide on tax acquiescence in Italy and on reclamo and tax mediation.

The mitigating circumstances under art. 13-bis

When full extinguishment of the debt is not possible before the opening of the trial, or concerns crimes other than those covered by art. 13, art. 13-bis still provides for a mitigating circumstance: payment of the tax debt, even through an instalment plan, before the trial is opened leads to a reduction of the penalty of up to one half and the exclusion of accessory penalties. The same article makes access to alternative proceedings, such as plea bargaining, conditional on the prior extinguishment of the debt or on the submission of an instalment plan, unless the debtor demonstrates the impossibility of paying.

The relationship between criminal and tax proceedings: the “double track”

The Italian system has historically been based on the principle of the “double track” (doppio binario): criminal proceedings and tax proceedings are autonomous and independent, can proceed in parallel, and can, in theory, reach different conclusions on the same facts. This autonomy means that acquittal in criminal proceedings does not automatically entail the annulment of the tax assessment, and vice versa a criminal conviction does not bind the tax judge in assessing the evidence, which in tax proceedings is subject to different rules (for example, limitations on witness evidence).

The reform of Legislative Decree 87/2024: the main changes

Legislative Decree no. 87 of 14 June 2024, implementing the delegation for tax reform, significantly affected the tax criminal system, aiming at greater proportionality and a softening of the double track. Among the main changes: the introduction of new grounds of non-punishability linked to the filing of amended returns and to payment of the debt even in the presence of a liquidity crisis not attributable to the taxpayer; the redefinition of the ground of non-punishability for particular tenuousness of the fact in relation to the tax thresholds; and, above all, the introduction of the new article 21-bis, dedicated to the relationship between a criminal judgment and tax proceedings.

The new article 21-bis: the effect of a criminal judgment on tax proceedings

Article 21-bis, introduced by Legislative Decree 87/2024, establishes that a final criminal judgment of acquittal because the fact does not exist or the defendant did not commit it, issued at the end of the trial, has the effect of res judicata in the pending tax proceedings with respect to the same material facts on which the judgment is based. This is an important corrective to the traditional double track, designed to reduce the risk of contradictory decisions on the same facts between the criminal judge and the tax judge, while still keeping the mutual autonomy of the two proceedings as the general rule.

The ne bis in idem principle and ECHR case law

The combination of a criminal sanction and an administrative tax sanction for the same fact has long raised doubts of compatibility with the ne bis in idem principle, enshrined in article 4 of Protocol no. 7 to the European Convention on Human Rights. The Strasbourg Court, in the well-known Grande Stevens v. Italy judgment (2014), held that particularly severe administrative sanctions may, in substance, have a criminal nature for Convention purposes, laying the groundwork for a rethinking of the double-track sanctioning system. Subsequent case law, both of the ECHR and of the EU Court of Justice, has since clarified that the combination remains admissible where there is a sufficiently close substantive and temporal connection between the two proceedings, preventing the taxpayer from being subjected to an uncoordinated double judgment for the same conduct.

The 2023 “Decreto Bollette” and its amendments

Article 23 of Decree-Law 34/2023 (the so-called “Decreto Bollette”), converted with amendments by Law 56/2023, introduced significant changes on seizure and confiscation in tax crimes, in particular extending the possibilities of suspending a preventive seizure when the taxpayer has committed to paying the debt through an instalment plan granted by the Revenue-Collection Agency, and regulating the effects of default on such instalment plans on the pending criminal procedure. The rule is part of a broader trend of reforms aimed at better coordinating the asset dimension of criminal proceedings with the instalment tools already available in the tax field.

How to behave to avoid criminal exposure

Preventing criminal exposure starts with proper bookkeeping and accurate preparation of tax returns, but also with constant monitoring of the quantitative thresholds set by Legislative Decree 74/2000, especially when the business is growing rapidly. When past irregularities emerge, prompt voluntary disclosure and spontaneous regularisation can prevent an administrative violation from turning into a crime, or can in any case trigger the grounds of non-punishability or the mitigating circumstances provided for by articles 13 and 13-bis. If a tax audit report or an assessment notice with potential criminal relevance is received, it is essential to coordinate the tax defence with the criminal defence from the outset, carefully weighing the timing and manner of any payment of the debt.

Why rely on a commercialista for tax crime matters

Correctly assessing whether a conduct exceeds the thresholds of criminal relevance, promptly identifying the applicable grounds of non-punishability, and structuring a tax debt repayment plan that also protects on the criminal side requires specific technical expertise and constant regulatory updating, especially in light of recent reforms. Studio Savia supports businesses and professionals in managing these situations, with the goal of reducing tax and criminal risk and of properly coordinating, when necessary, the tax strategy with the criminal one.

For an official overview of the regulatory framework, see the official page of the Revenue Agency and the text of Legislative Decree 74/2000 on the Normattiva portal.

Frequently asked questions about tax crimes in Italy

What are the main tax crimes under Italian law?

Legislative Decree 74/2000 governs return-based crimes (fraudulent, false or omitted declaration, issuance of false invoices) and collection-based crimes (failure to pay withholding taxes and VAT, undue offsetting, fraudulent evasion of tax payment).

From what amount of evaded tax does a tax crime arise?

Thresholds vary by offence, generally between 30,000 and 150,000 euros of evaded tax; some crimes, such as fraudulent declaration through false invoices, have no minimum threshold.

Does paying the tax debt avoid criminal proceedings?

For the crimes of omitted payment and undue offsetting, full extinguishment of the debt before the trial excludes punishability under art. 13 of Legislative Decree 74/2000; for other crimes it constitutes a mitigating circumstance under art. 13-bis.

What does the new article 21-bis introduced by Legislative Decree 87/2024 provide?

It provides that a final criminal judgment of acquittal on the merits has the effect of res judicata in tax proceedings with respect to the same material facts, reducing the risk of contradictory decisions between the two proceedings.

Do criminal and tax proceedings move forward together?

Generally yes, under the double-track principle the two proceedings are in principle autonomous and independent, although the most recent reforms have introduced mechanisms for greater coordination, such as the new art. 21-bis.

Tax crimes

Received a notice of investigation or a charge for tax offences?

Tell us your situation in confidence: we will assess your position, the criminal thresholds and the possible defence and regularisation strategies.

Prima Analisi Gratuita - Aziende (EN)

Prefer to talk it through? Call the firm on +39 011 349 0809 (Mon–Fri 8:30 am–1:00 pm / 2:00–5:30 pm CET) or message us on WhatsApp.