When due diligence is required: transfers, mergers and even renting commercial premises

When due diligence is required is a question usually associated with major transactions: buying a company, a merger, a demerger. In practice the moment when it is needed comes up far more often and with far less ceremony. It is needed every time that, by signing a contract, you step into someone else’s position: their assets, their relationships, their premises. And in Italy the tax authorities, creditors and employees look at the substance of what changed hands, not at the name written on the contract.

This guide lines up the moments when due diligence is required under Italian law, from the classic cases to the one almost nobody considers: renting commercial premises where another business used to operate. Anyone who takes over without checking who was there before risks having the arrangement treated as a business transfer, with the predecessor’s debts attached.

In brief

  • Due diligence is not only for buying or selling a company: it is needed whenever you take over from someone in a business, an estate or a contractual relationship.
  • In a business transfer the buyer is jointly liable for the seller’s tax debts for the year of the transfer and the two previous years, up to the value of the business (art. 14 of Legislative Decree 472/1997): the tax clearance certificate releases the buyer.
  • In a share deal there is no filter: the company keeps all its debts, known and unknown. Protection comes only from the checks and from contractual warranties.
  • In a demerger the beneficiary companies are jointly liable for the demerged company’s tax debts without the civil-law cap of the net assets received (art. 173(13) of the Italian Income Tax Code).
  • When renting commercial premises, if you also take over the previous operator’s equipment, licence, staff or customers, the arrangement can be requalified as a business transfer: art. 14, art. 2560 and art. 2112 of the Civil Code then apply.
  • Before signing: historical company register extract on the previous operator, tax clearance certificate, checks on the landlord and on the property, separate contracts at market value.

What due diligence is, and why the moment matters more than the name

Due diligence is the set of legal, tax, accounting and employment checks carried out before taking on a commitment, to know what you are really acquiring and which liabilities may follow. We covered the content and the method in our corporate due diligence checklist and in the guide on what due diligence is in a business acquisition. Here the angle is different: when due diligence is required.

The answer depends on a simple question: with this contract, am I stepping into someone else’s position? If so, Italian law provides in many cases that debts, employment relationships and tax liabilities follow the business or the assets, regardless of what the parties called the transaction. Under civil law a business (“azienda”) is the set of assets organised for the exercise of an enterprise (art. 2555 of the Civil Code), and for the tax authorities and the courts what counts is the actual economic function of what is transferred.

Transfer of a business or of a business branch: the classic case

When you buy a business or a business branch in Italy, the passing of liabilities is governed by three provisions of the Civil Code and one tax provision:

  • Art. 2560 of the Civil Code: the buyer is liable for the debts of the transferred business if they appear in the mandatory accounting books; the seller is not released without the creditors’ consent.
  • Art. 2112 of the Civil Code: employment relationships continue with the buyer, who is jointly liable with the seller for the claims employees accrued before the transfer.
  • Art. 2558 of the Civil Code: the buyer takes over the contracts entered into for the running of the business, except those of a personal nature.
  • Art. 14 of Legislative Decree 472/1997: the transferee is jointly liable with the transferor for taxes and penalties relating to violations committed in the year of the transfer and in the two previous years, and for those already imposed and challenged in the same period, even if they refer to older violations.

The tax liability has three limits: the benefit of prior enforcement against the transferor, the value of the business or branch transferred, and the debt resulting from the tax offices’ records at the date of the transfer. The limits fall away if the transfer is made to defraud tax claims, including through the piecemeal transfer of individual assets; fraud is presumed if the transfer takes place within six months of the discovery of a criminally relevant violation. The same rules apply to all forms of business transfer, including a contribution in kind (paragraph 5-ter).

From 1 January 2027 the provision moves, with unchanged content, into art. 16 of the Consolidated Act on tax penalties (Legislative Decree 173/2024), whose entry into force was postponed by the “Milleproroghe” decree.

The tax clearance certificate: how to request it and what it releases

Paragraph 3 of art. 14 provides the protective tool: on request, the Italian Revenue Agency issues a certificate on pending disputes and on those already settled but unpaid (the “certificato dei carichi pendenti”). A negative certificate fully releases the buyer; failure to issue it within forty days of the request has the same effect. The request is filed with the form available on the Agency’s website at the provincial office competent for the transferor’s tax domicile, also by certified e-mail (PEC) or through the “Consegna documenti e istanze” online service.

Two practical points: the request must be made by the transferor or with their authorisation, so it should be provided for in the preliminary agreement; and the certificate covers only the Revenue Agency. For INPS and INAIL contributions you need the DURC and the contribution statement; for debts entrusted to the collection agency (Agenzia delle Entrate-Riscossione) the “estratto di ruolo”, which the taxpayer can request for themselves and hand to the buyer.

Share deals: due diligence with no filter

Whoever buys the quotas or shares of a company does not buy assets: they buy the container with everything inside it. No rule limits the debts that follow the shares, because the debtor remains the same legal entity. Art. 14 does not apply, art. 2560 does not apply, and a tax assessment on a tax year still open, that is the last five years or seven in case of a missing return, hits the company now in the hands of the new shareholder.

This is why due diligence on a share deal is the broadest: financial statements and tax returns, tax and social-security positions, litigation, contracts, guarantees given, banking relationships. Alongside the checks come the contractual tools: representations and warranties from the seller, indemnity obligations, escrow of part of the price, price adjustment based on net financial position at closing. Here too it is useful to obtain the company’s tax clearance certificate, the estratto di ruolo and the DURC, requested by the company itself.

Mergers, demergers, contributions and conversions

Extraordinary transactions change the legal form but do not erase debts. Due diligence here serves both parties, because liability can travel in directions you would not expect.

Merger

In a merger the resulting or absorbing company takes on the rights and obligations of the participating companies and continues in all their relationships, including litigation (art. 2504-bis of the Civil Code). There is no limit of value or time: the tax, social-security and commercial debts of the merged companies arrive in full. Art. 15 of Legislative Decree 472/1997 confirms this for penalties.

Demerger

The demerger is the case where the civil-law rule and the tax rule diverge. Under the Civil Code each beneficiary company is jointly liable for the demerged company’s unpaid debts, but only up to the net assets assigned to it (art. 2506-quater(3)). For tax debts, instead, art. 173(13) of the Income Tax Code provides that the beneficiaries are jointly liable for taxes, penalties and interest owed by the demerged company for the periods before the demerger, without that cap. The Constitutional Court (judgment no. 90/2018) found the difference legitimate and the Court of Cassation (order no. 10239/2020) applied it to partial demergers too. Whoever receives a branch in a demerger must therefore check the tax position of the entire demerged company.

Contribution in kind and conversion

A contribution of a business is treated as a transfer for the purposes of art. 14 (paragraph 5-ter): the receiving company is liable for the contributing company’s tax debts within the same limits. A company conversion transfers nothing, because the entity remains the same, but it can change who is liable: the partners of a partnership that converts into a company limited by shares are not released from the earlier company obligations without the creditors’ consent (art. 2500-quinquies). And whoever joins an existing partnership as a partner is also liable for the company obligations that arose before joining (art. 2269 of the Civil Code).

Renting a business or a business branch

The rental of a business is often chosen precisely to limit risk: you run it without buying it. That is partly true. Art. 2112 of the Civil Code applies to any business transfer, rental included, so employees pass to the tenant with their claims. On art. 14 of Legislative Decree 472/1997 scholars are divided: the prevailing view excludes it, because the owner keeps the assets and the creditors’ guarantee is not reduced, but paragraph 5-ter speaks of “all forms of business transfer” and the question is not settled.

The bigger risk, however, is requalification. With order no. 23049 of 10 July 2026 the Court of Cassation held that a contract called a business rental can be treated as a transfer for VAT and income-tax purposes on the basis of the actual economic function of the transaction, taking into account elements outside the contract as well. In the case decided, what counted was that the owner ceased its activity right after signing, that the activity continued in the same premises and that goods, equipment and staff passed to the tenant for consideration. Once requalified, the transaction brings with it the challenge to the VAT deducted and the recovery of income.

Vacated shop seen from inside with boxes and keys on the floor: due diligence before a commercial lease
Before signing a commercial lease, check who was operating in the premises and what you are taking over.

Renting commercial premises: the case nobody considers

This is the most underestimated moment. An entrepreneur rents premises where, until the month before, a bar, a shop or a workshop was operating. They sign a lease with the owner of the property, not with the previous operator, and assume they have nothing to do with them. Often, however, for convenience, they buy the fittings and equipment from the previous tenant, take over the licence or the SCIA notification, keep the sign, hire the same staff and carry on with the same suppliers.

Put together, these elements describe exactly a business within the meaning of art. 2555 of the Civil Code: an organised set of assets passing from one entrepreneur to another. That the transfer took place through three separate contracts rather than a notarial deed of sale does not change the substance, and it is precisely on substance that tax assessments are based.

When renting premises becomes a business takeover

The indicators that the Revenue Agency, INPS and the courts rely on are recurrent:

  • the previous operator ceases its activity at the same time as the new tenant moves in;
  • the activity continues in the same premises and in the same line of business;
  • fittings, equipment, stock or goods are bought from the previous operator, even with separate invoices;
  • the licence, the SCIA or the health authorisations are taken over through a change-of-ownership filing;
  • the sign, the name, the telephone number, the social media profiles and the supplier contracts are kept;
  • staff who worked for the previous operator are hired, even only in part;
  • a sum is paid for “goodwill” or as a “key money” payment, whatever name it is given.

The more indicators coincide, the more likely it is that the transaction will be qualified as a business transfer in fragmented form. Art. 14(4) says so expressly when dealing with fraud: the limits on liability do not apply if the transfer is carried out “including through the piecemeal transfer of individual assets”.

What the incoming tenant risks

  • The predecessor’s tax debts: joint liability under art. 14 for taxes and penalties of the year of the takeover and the two previous years, up to the value of the business deemed transferred.
  • Book debts: liability under art. 2560 of the Civil Code for the debts shown in the previous operator’s books, suppliers included.
  • Employees: continuity of employment under art. 2112 and joint liability for severance pay (TFR), wages and contribution arrears, with consequences for the DURC.
  • Taxes on the transaction: a business transfer is outside the scope of VAT (art. 2(3)(b) of Presidential Decree 633/1972) and is subject to registration tax; the VAT paid on the invoices for fittings and equipment can be challenged as wrongly deducted and registration tax can be claimed on the goodwill.
  • Litigation: the defence rests on proving that there was no business, that is that the assets bought were not organised and that the activity was started from scratch. That is a hard proof when sign, licence and staff are the same.

The checks before signing the lease

Due diligence on commercial premises is short and inexpensive, but it must be done before signing. It covers three fronts.

1. Who was there before. Historical company register extract (visura camerale storica) on the previous operator and the date of cessation; protests and prejudicial records; checks on any insolvency proceedings in progress. If you buy assets from them, obtain the art. 14 tax clearance certificate, the DURC and the estratto di ruolo, and include an indemnity clause for earlier debts in the contract. The assets must be bought under a separate contract, at market price, with an inventory attached: a disproportionate price is the first sign of goodwill paid under another name.

2. The owner of the property. Land registry search for mortgages, attachments and seizures: a lease signed after an attachment has been registered is not enforceable against whoever buys at auction (art. 2923 of the Civil Code). Check that the landlord is not in judicial liquidation, because in that case the contract continues but with the receiver. Check the title deed and any building regulations, which may prohibit certain activities.

3. The property. Cadastral category and intended use compatible with the activity (C/1 for retail, C/3 for a workshop); habitability certificate; planning and building compliance; declarations of conformity for the systems; health and hygiene requirements for food businesses. For utilities, ask for the meter readings and the closure of the previous tenant’s contracts, so as to activate a new supply rather than take over a contract in arrears. The previous tenant’s service charges do not pass to the newcomer, but it is worth obtaining an up-to-date statement from the building administrator.

If the checks reveal significant debts of the previous operator, the solution is not to give up the premises: it is to keep the transactions clearly separate, buy nothing from them, file a new SCIA rather than take over the licence, and document the start of a new activity. Where, instead, the aim really is to take over the activity, better to call it by its name: a business transfer with a notarial deed, tax clearance certificate and warranties, which costs registration tax but gives certainty about what is being bought.

Other moments when due diligence is required

Buying business premises. Beyond mortgages, attachments and building irregularities, whoever buys a unit in a condominium is jointly liable with the seller for the service charges of the current year and the previous one (art. 63(4) of the implementing provisions of the Civil Code). The urban planning certificate and the integrated technical report are the minimum.

Inheritance and generational succession. Heirs are jointly liable for the taxes owed by the deceased (art. 65 of Presidential Decree 600/1973), while penalties are not passed on (art. 8 of Legislative Decree 472/1997). Before accepting an estate with a business in it, the inventory and acceptance with benefit of inventory (art. 484 of the Civil Code) are the due diligence of the case. We discuss it in our guide on intestate succession.

A new partner or investor joining. Whoever subscribes to a capital increase or joins a partnership inherits the existing situation. For partnerships art. 2269 of the Civil Code applies: liability also for earlier obligations.

Vendor due diligence. The seller too has an interest in doing it before putting the business on the market: finding the critical points first makes it possible to fix them or price them, instead of suffering a price reduction or an indemnity claim late in the negotiation.

Financing and guarantees. Whoever gives personal guarantees for a company, or buys receivables, takes on risks that depend on someone else’s soundness. The checks are the same as for a share deal, on a smaller scale.

When due diligence is required: summary table

MomentWhat follows the transactionKey ruleMinimum check
Transfer of a business or branchBook debts, employees, contracts, tax debts (year + 2 previous, up to the value)Arts. 2560, 2112, 2558 Civil Code; art. 14 Legislative Decree 472/1997Tax clearance certificate, DURC, estratto di ruolo, accounting books
Share dealEverything, without limits: the company stays the sameNo statutory filterFull due diligence + contractual warranties, escrow, price adjustment
MergerAll rights and obligations of the merged companiesArt. 2504-bis Civil Code; art. 15 Legislative Decree 472/1997Due diligence on each participating company
DemergerCivil debts up to the net assets assigned; tax debts without limitArt. 2506-quater Civil Code; art. 173(13) Income Tax CodeTax position of the entire demerged company
Contribution of a businessAs for a business transferArt. 14(5-ter) Legislative Decree 472/1997Tax clearance certificate of the contributing company
Business rentalEmployees; risk of requalification as a transferArt. 2112 Civil Code; Cass. order 23049/2026Contract consistent with substance: term, rent, no transfer of assets for consideration
Commercial lease with takeoverIf assets, licence or staff are taken over: as for a business transferArts. 2555, 2560, 2112 Civil Code; art. 14 Legislative Decree 472/1997Historical extract on the previous operator, tax clearance, separate contracts at market value, new SCIA
Purchase of propertyMortgages, attachments, service charges for the current and previous yearArt. 2808 Civil Code; art. 63 implementing provisionsLand registry search, planning compliance, condominium statement
Inheritance with a businessThe deceased’s taxes, not the penaltiesArt. 65 Presidential Decree 600/1973; art. 8 Legislative Decree 472/1997; art. 484 Civil CodeInventory, acceptance with benefit of inventory
Joining a partnershipObligations arising even before joiningArt. 2269 Civil CodeFinancial statements, debts, guarantees given

Frequently asked questions on when due diligence is needed

If I rent only the walls, without buying anything from the previous operator, am I at risk?

No, if you really acquire nothing: no assets, no licence, no employees, no payment for goodwill. In that case there is no business transfer. What remains are the checks on the landlord and on the property, which concern the soundness of the lease and not the predecessor’s debts.

Does the tax clearance certificate also cover INPS and collection notices?

No. The certificate under art. 14 concerns the Revenue Agency’s disputes. For contributions you need the DURC; for debts entrusted to Agenzia delle Entrate-Riscossione you need the estratto di ruolo, which the taxpayer can request for themselves and hand to the other party.

How far back can the tax authorities go with the buyer of a business?

Joint liability covers violations of the year in which the transfer takes place and of the two previous years, plus penalties already imposed and challenged in that period even if they refer to older violations. In case of fraud, including presumed fraud, the limits do not apply.

In a share deal can I ask for the tax clearance certificate?

Not the one under art. 14, because there is no business transfer. The company can, however, request its own ordinary tax clearance certificate and hand it to the buyer, together with the estratto di ruolo and the DURC. It is a normal request in a negotiation.

Who pays for due diligence on commercial premises?

The incoming tenant, because they are the one running the risk. It involves searches and certificates at modest cost and a few hours of professional work: a fraction of what an assessment for the previous operator’s debts would cost.

What changes from 2027 for the transferee’s liability?

Nothing in substance. From 1 January 2027 art. 14 of Legislative Decree 472/1997 is replaced by art. 16 of the Consolidated Act on tax penalties (Legislative Decree 173/2024), which reproduces its content.

Sources

Knowing when due diligence is required is not a cost added to a transaction: it is the way to know what you are buying, renting or inheriting before it is too late to renegotiate. And it applies to multi-million deals as much as to the lease of a neighbourhood shop.

Before you sign

Do you want a check on the premises, the business or the shares you are about to take over in Italy?

Studio Savia carries out due diligence proportionate to the transaction: from searches and the tax clearance certificate for commercial premises to the full analysis of a corporate acquisition.

Let’s talk →

Prefer to talk it through? Call the firm on +39 011 349 0809 (Mon–Fri 8:30 am–1:00 pm / 2:00–5:30 pm CET) or message us on WhatsApp.