Since 2024 every Italian tax assessment is preceded by a draft assessment (the schema di atto): the Agenzia delle Entrate states in advance what it intends to challenge, the taxpayer has at least 60 days to reply, and the final notice comes afterwards.
But what happens when the final notice challenges something different from what was written in the draft assessment? The first-instance tax court of Milan, with judgment no. 2613/2026, answered that the adversarial procedure must be informed and effective: if the office radically changes the legal characterisation of the facts after the observations, without reopening the exchange, the act is annullable. This guide explains the case, the reasoning and how to compare the draft assessment and the notice when they arrive.
In brief
- A construction company had received a draft assessment for VAT and IRAP 2019 and 2020 challenging costs for objectively non-existent transactions and the reverse-charge VAT on subcontracts; it replied documenting that the suppliers existed and the works had been performed and paid.
- The final notice accepted that the works were real, but reclassified the subcontracts as unlawful supply of labour, with new consequences for VAT and IRAP. No new adversarial exchange was opened on the point.
- The court found a “radically different characterisation of the facts”: challenging non-existence and challenging labour supply require different defences and evidence. The adversarial procedure under art. 6-bis of the Taxpayer’s Statute had been neither informed nor effective, and the notice was annulled in its VAT part.
- Not every difference between the draft assessment and the notice annuls the act: what matters is whether the change was substantial and prevented the taxpayer from defending itself on the real grounds. The company passed the resistance test by listing the defences it would have raised.
- Practical rule: compare the draft assessment and the notice line by line on facts, legal characterisation, rules, periods and amounts; if the challenge has changed, the defect must be pleaded in the appeal within 60 days.
Contents
What the draft assessment is and what it is for
The draft assessment is the communication by which the office, before issuing an assessment notice or another appealable act, sets out to the taxpayer the findings it intends to make, the rules applied and the amounts. It is provided by art. 6-bis of the Taxpayer’s Statute (Law 212/2000), introduced by Legislative Decree 219/2023 in force since 18 January 2024 and adjusted by Legislative Decree 192/2025, and it applies to all taxes, including local ones. From the communication runs a period of not less than 60 days within which the taxpayer may file observations and documents or request access to the file; the final act cannot be adopted before expiry and must account for the observations received.
The purpose is simple: to avoid wrong acts, by bringing out before the assessment the clarifications that would otherwise emerge only in court. For it to work, the taxpayer must know precisely what it is accused of. This is the point on which the Milan judgment intervenes: a draft assessment challenging one thing, followed by a notice challenging another, is not an adversarial procedure but a formality. On the stages of the audit and the office’s powers before the draft, from bank investigations to access, see the guide on tax assessment powers in Italy.
The case: from non-existent transactions to supply of labour
The taxpayer is a construction company that uses subcontractors. For 2019 and 2020 the Agency sent it a draft assessment for VAT and IRAP with a precise challenge: the subcontractors’ invoices referred to objectively non-existent transactions, so the costs were non-deductible and the VAT accounted for under the reverse charge was non-deductible; the documentation on the suppliers was considered insufficient. The company replied within the deadline producing contracts, site documents, evidence of the existence and organisation of the subcontractors, of the performance of the works and of the payments.
The final assessment notice took note of that evidence: for income tax purposes the works were recognised as actually performed. But the office changed course: the subcontracts were reclassified as unlawful supply of labour disguised as contracting, and from this new characterisation it drew the consequences for VAT and IRAP. No adversarial exchange was opened on this new challenge: the taxpayer read it for the first time in the final act.
What the Milan tax court decided
The court, with judgment no. 2613/2026 filed in June 2026, upheld the appeal as to the VAT component of the assessment, finding a breach of the in-procedure adversarial exchange. The reasoning has three steps.
A radically different characterisation
Challenging that a transaction does not exist and challenging that a genuine contract is in fact a supply of labour are different accusations, requiring different evidence. In the first case the taxpayer must show that the works were done and paid; in the second it must show that the subcontractor had its own organisation, bore the business risk and directed its own workers. The court speaks of a “radically different characterisation of the facts”: the change does not touch a detail but the whole line of defence.
The adversarial procedure must be informed and effective
Art. 6-bis is not satisfied by the mere sending of a draft assessment: it requires that the taxpayer be put in a position to defend itself on the real grounds of the assessment. Basing the final notice on a fact pattern never put to the taxpayer breaches that requirement. The court cites Supreme Court order no. 24881/2025, which bars the office from changing the grounds of the act in court to the detriment of the defence, and applies the same principle to the administrative stage: what cannot be done before the judge cannot be done between the draft assessment and the notice either.
Not every difference annuls the act: the resistance test
The court is careful not to turn the principle into an automatism. Between a draft assessment and a final notice there can be legitimate differences, for example a reduction of the amounts after the observations, a correction of a calculation, a finding dropped. The defect arises when the change is substantial and has prevented the taxpayer from replying on the actual grounds. In the case at hand the company passed the resistance test by listing the specific defences it would have raised had labour supply been challenged in the draft assessment: genuineness of the contracts, organisational structure of the suppliers, business risk, relations with the workers.
Why the judgment matters to anyone receiving a draft assessment today
It is a first-instance decision on the merits and, as such, does not bind other judges; on this specific point the Supreme Court has not yet ruled. But it is one of the first concrete applications of art. 6-bis to a case of “moving challenge”, and it indicates a method that applies to everyone: the perimeter of the defence is set by the draft assessment, and the final notice must stay within that perimeter or reopen the exchange. The phenomenon is frequent: the office challenges the non-existence of the transactions, the taxpayer dismantles it with documents, and the notice falls back on a reclassification, on anti-economic conduct or on abuse of law, which are new challenges.
The judgment adds to another preliminary check that the Supreme Court made decisive in 2026: the act cannot be signed before expiry of the period for observations, and what counts is the signing date, not the service date. We cover it in the guide on the assessment signed before the 60 days from the tax audit report. Together, the two checks cover the two most common pathologies of the draft assessment: haste and the change of challenge.
How to compare the draft assessment and the assessment notice
When the final notice arrives, before arguing about the figures it pays to make a systematic comparison with the draft assessment. It takes a two-column table and an hour of work.
- Facts challenged. Are the transactions, suppliers, relationships, accounts and tax periods the same? A new fact, never mentioned in the draft assessment, is the first warning sign.
- Legal characterisation. Does the notice use the same categories as the draft assessment (objective non-existence, subjective non-existence, labour supply, anti-economic conduct, abuse of law, foreign-dressed company) or does it introduce new ones? The change of category is the heart of the Milan judgment.
- Rules applied. Are the articles cited the same? A new rule as a rule implies a new challenge.
- Amounts and calculation method. A reduction after the observations is legitimate; an increase, or a different reconstruction method, must be explained in the notice and as a rule requires a new adversarial exchange.
- Reply to the observations. The notice must account for what the taxpayer argued. If the observations were accepted on the original point and the office changed the challenge to keep the act alive, the ground of appeal is ready.
The comparison should be put in writing and attached to the appeal, together with the draft assessment, the observations with the transmission receipts and the notice with the service record. And it should be accompanied by the resistance test: the list of defences, documents and witnesses that would have been brought had the new challenge been anticipated. Without this list the judge might consider the change irrelevant.
What to do if the challenge has changed
- Plead the defect in the tax appeal within 60 days of service of the notice, as the main ground: breach of art. 6-bis for an adversarial procedure that was not informed and effective, with a request for annulment of the act. On the merits, in the alternative, contest the new characterisation.
- Request in parallel annulment in self-review, attaching the comparison between draft assessment and notice: it does not suspend the deadlines, but some offices prefer to reissue a correct act rather than defend in court a notice born this way.
- Consider a tax settlement agreement only with the defect on the table: the request suspends the appeal deadline for 90 days and, in negotiation, a well-founded procedural defect weighs on the reduction of the claim. Signing the settlement, however, makes the act final and waives the defect.
- If the reclassification touches criminal thresholds, for example because unlawful labour supply goes together with invoices for legally non-existent transactions, check first the picture of tax crimes in Italy: the criminal Supreme Court, with judgment 25588/2026, held that invoices issued under a sham contract can amount to fraudulent tax return.
- Bear in mind that, if the act is annulled for the adversarial defect, the office can reissue it with a correct draft assessment, provided its power has not lapsed: the time that passes is a factor in the strategy.
| Stage | Deadline | Reference |
|---|---|---|
| Communication of the draft assessment | Before the appealable act; mandatory save automated acts and danger for collection | art. 6-bis(1)-(2) L. 212/2000 |
| Observations and access to the file | Not less than 60 days from the communication | art. 6-bis(3) L. 212/2000 |
| Adoption of the final notice | After expiry of the period; must state reasons on the observations | art. 6-bis(3)-(4); Cass. 23073/2026 |
| Challenge changed in the notice | Annullability if the different characterisation is substantial | CGT Milan 2613/2026; Cass. ord. 24881/2025 |
| Appeal against the notice | 60 days from service | art. 21 Legislative Decree 546/1992 |
| Settlement request | Suspends the appeal deadline for 90 days | art. 6 Legislative Decree 218/1997 |
For the practical side there are two guides: what to do with the draft assessment in the pre-assessment hearing and the options after a tax assessment notice is served.
Frequently asked questions on the draft assessment
Is the draft assessment mandatory for all assessments?
Since 18 January 2024, yes, for all separately appealable acts of all taxes, except automated or substantially automated acts, settlements, formal checks and cases of well-founded danger for collection, stated in the act. A notice issued without a draft assessment when one was due is annullable.
Can I skip replying to the draft assessment and defend myself later?
You can, but it is a mistake: the observations fix the documentary basis, oblige the office to state reasons and, if the office changes the challenge, show that the adversarial procedure had real content. Those who do not reply also risk being told that the adversarial defect caused them no prejudice.
Can the notice reduce the amounts of the draft assessment?
Yes, and that is the normal course of the adversarial procedure: if the observations are well founded, the notice reduces or drops the findings. The problem arises when, having dropped the original finding, the office introduces a new one to keep the claim alive.
What does resistance test mean?
It is the demonstration that, had the adversarial procedure been respected, the taxpayer would have had something concrete to say: documents, arguments, witnesses. For the art. 6-bis defect many commentators consider it unnecessary, but the Milan judgment checked it anyway; it is therefore always worth setting it out in the appeal.
Does the Milan judgment apply outside Lombardy?
It does not bind other judges, but it is a reasoned decision applying a principle already affirmed by the Supreme Court for the trial stage (order 24881/2025). It can be cited in any appeal; the outcome will depend on the ability to show that the change of challenge was substantial.
If the office changes the challenge during the adversarial procedure, must it send a new draft assessment?
The rule does not say so expressly, but the logic of the judgment is this: if the new challenge requires different defences, the taxpayer must have a new period to reply. Failing that, the act is exposed to annulment. For the full picture of the tools after the notice, from negotiation to trial, see the guide on tax litigation in Italy.
Sources
- First-instance tax court of Milan, judgment no. 2613/2026 (commentary by Osservatorio Giustizia Tributaria, 24 September 2026, in Italian)
- Law 27 July 2000, no. 212, Taxpayer’s Statute, art. 6-bis (preventive adversarial procedure and draft assessment)
- Legislative Decree 30 December 2023, no. 219 (introduction of art. 6-bis)
- Cass., Section V, order no. 24881/2025 (prohibition on changing the grounds of the act in court); Cass., Tax Division, judgment 12 July 2026, no. 23073 (signing date of the act)
- Cass. crim., judgment 9 July 2026, no. 25588 (sham contracting and fraudulent return)
- Legislative Decree 31 December 1992, no. 546, art. 21 (appeal deadline)
- Department of Tax Justice, Guide to the tax process and database of first- and second-instance case law
The draft assessment exists to tell the taxpayer what it is accused of, not to start a clock. If the final notice accuses it of something else, there has been no adversarial procedure, and the Milan judgment says the act can fall. For anyone receiving an assessment the first thing to do is not to count the money, but to compare the two documents.
Received a draft assessment, or a notice different from the draft?
We compare the two acts and tell you whether the adversarial procedure was respected
Studio Savia assists businesses, professionals and foreign companies from the preventive adversarial procedure to the appeal. Send us the draft assessment, the observations and the notice: the first assessment is free.
Send the documents →Prefer to talk it through? Call the firm on +39 011 349 0809 (Mon–Fri 8:30 am–1:00 pm / 2:00–5:30 pm CET) or message us on WhatsApp.
