A VAT return filed more than 90 days after the deadline is, under Italian law, an omitted return. From this the Agenzia delle Entrate often draws a consequence the law does not state: the credit shown in a late VAT return no longer exists and the refund must be denied.
The first-instance tax court of Pescara (Corte di giustizia tributaria di primo grado), in judgment no. 772/2026 filed on 26 October 2026, said the opposite: the credit arises from the transactions and from the deduction mechanism, not from the return, and if the documents prove the substance the refund is due. This guide explains the case, the court’s reasoning and, above all, what to do when a VAT refund is denied in Italy because of a late VAT return. The full judgment, anonymised, is at the end.
In brief
- A company established in another EU Member State and registered for VAT in Italy had filed its 2024 VAT return (year 2023) on 2 December 2024, more than 90 days after the 30 April deadline. The Agency denied the refund of 6,067 euro because the return was “omitted”.
- The court annulled the denial: an omitted return has formal effects, but it does not extinguish the VAT credit, which must be recognised if the substantive requirements of the deduction are proven and the right is exercised by the deadline of the return for the second following year.
- The evidence was documentary: customs declaration, purchase ledger, periodic VAT settlements, intra-EU sales invoice, self-invoice ledgers. The office had challenged none of it, only the delay.
- Costs were awarded against the Agency: 1,000 euro plus statutory extras. The judgment is first-instance and can be appealed within 60 days of service or six months of filing.
- Anyone who receives a denial has 60 days to appeal: the late VAT return must still be filed, the documents gathered at once, and a favourable judgment served on the office to shorten the timeline.
Contents
The case: a late VAT return and a denied credit
The appellant is a company based in Spain, directly registered for VAT in Italy, where in 2023 it had carried out a single commercial transaction: an import of goods with a customs declaration dated 22 August 2023 (taxable base 27,575.88 euro, import VAT 6,066.69 euro) and the subsequent intra-EU supply of the same goods to a customer in another Member State, for 55,420 euro, exempt under art. 41 of Decree-Law 331/1993. Transport had been invoiced by a foreign carrier and VAT accounted for under the reverse charge. The result was an annual VAT credit of 6,067 euro, claimed entirely as a refund.
The problem was the calendar. The 2024 VAT return, for 2023, was transmitted on 2 December 2024, more than 90 days after the 30 April 2024 deadline. Art. 2(7) of Presidential Decree 322/1998 provides that returns filed more than 90 days late are treated as omitted, while still serving as a basis for collecting the tax due. On this basis the Pescara operations centre of the Agenzia delle Entrate, by a decision of 12 December 2024 served on 2 January 2025, denied the refund: according to the office, an omitted return cannot show an excess to be carried forward or claimed back under art. 30 of Presidential Decree 633/1972.
The appeal was lodged on 18 March 2025. The Agency joined the proceedings asking for dismissal and relying, in support of the time-barring nature of the deadlines, on the rules on refunds to non-residents and on national and EU case law. The case was argued in public hearing on 19 October 2026 and decided the same day.
What the Pescara tax court decided
The court upheld the appeal, annulled the denial, declared the company’s right to a refund of 6,067 euro and ordered the Agency to pay costs. The reasoning has three steps.
A late VAT return does not cancel the credit
The judge starts from an undisputed point: the return was transmitted more than 90 days late and is therefore, for the formal purposes set by the rule, omitted. But from this, the court writes, no automatic extinction of the VAT credit follows, because the credit “originates from the taxable transactions and from the statutory deduction mechanism, not from the return, which is a declaration of knowledge”. The annual return, in other words, reports a credit that already exists; it neither creates nor destroys it.
The Joint Divisions precedent and the second-year deadline
The court follows the line of Supreme Court case law opened by Cass., Joint Divisions, 8 September 2016, no. 17757, and continued by Cass. 8131/2018, 19938/2018, 3066/2023 and order 12250/2024: even without the annual return, the excess tax resulting from the periodic settlements and payments must be recognised if the taxpayer claims it by the deadline of the return for the second year following the one in which the right arose and proves the substantive requirements of the deduction: purchases made by a taxable person, subject to VAT and intended for taxable transactions. It is not the return that founds the entitlement to the credit, but the evidence.
In the case at hand the return for 2023 had been filed on 2 December 2024, well within the deadline of the return for the second following year. No substantive time bar, therefore. The court also cites the case law of the Court of Justice of the EU on the principle of neutrality (Collée, Astone, Firma Hans Bühler, Wilo Salmson, Luxury Trust Automobil): deduction or refund must be granted where the substantive requirements are met despite the failure to meet formal ones, without prejudice to the Member States’ power to set reasonable limitation periods.
Proof of the substantive requirements
The third step is the one that decides the case. The court lists the documents produced and checks their consistency: the customs declaration with MRN, identifying the company as importer and showing taxable base and VAT; the purchase ledger recording the same declaration with the same amounts; the third-quarter and annual settlements showing the same credit, carried into the fourth quarter; the sales invoice of 31 August 2023 documenting the intra-EU supply; the carrier’s invoice and the self-invoice ledgers confirming that VAT on transport was accounted for under the reverse charge. The return reflects this data (deductible VAT 7,561 euro, reverse-charge output VAT 1,494 euro, credit 6,067 euro) and the rounding from 6,066.69 to 6,067 is consistent.
Decisive, finally, is what the office did not do: it did not dispute the reality of the import, the payment of the tax, the taxable status, the connection of the goods with the business or their use for transactions giving a right to deduct. The denial rested only on the formal lateness. A decision that derives the loss of the right to a refund from the mere classification of the return as omitted, the court concludes, is unlawful.
Why the judgment matters to Italian businesses too
The case concerns an EU company registered in Italy, but the principle applies to anyone: Italian companies that missed the VAT return because of an intermediary’s error, foreign companies with a fiscal representative or direct VAT registration that discover the Italian obligations late, taxpayers who filed a corrective return out of time. In all these cases the Agency tends to treat a late VAT return as the end of the credit, with an informal notice recovering the excess carried forward or with a refund denial.
Two clarifications are needed. First: an omitted return remains omitted, with the fixed penalty under art. 5 of Legislative Decree 471/1997 where no tax is due, and the delay cannot be cured by voluntary correction beyond 90 days. The judgment does not reward the delay: it says the delay does not cost the credit.
Second: the “second following year” deadline cited by the Supreme Court comes from the text of art. 19 of Presidential Decree 633/1972 before 2017; since 2017 the ordinary deadline for exercising the deduction coincides with the return for the year in which the right arose. Case law, however, continues to treat the two-year term as the substantive limit for claiming the credit resulting from the periodic settlements, and this is exactly the reading adopted in Pescara. It is ground on which the Agency may insist on appeal, which is why the documentary evidence must be flawless.
What to do when a VAT refund is denied because of a late VAT return
A refund denial is an appealable act (art. 19 of Legislative Decree 546/1992) and the tax appeal must be served within 60 days of service of the denial. In those 60 days it pays to do, in order, these things.
- File the return, even if late. A late VAT return that has been filed counts as a declaration of knowledge and fixes the data of the credit; a return never filed forces you to reconstruct everything before the judge. If it has not yet been transmitted, transmit it at once, paying the fixed penalty.
- Rebuild the credit document by document. Purchase invoices or customs declarations, VAT ledgers, periodic settlements (LIPE), proof of payment of the tax, sales invoices showing the use for taxable or exempt-with-credit transactions. The figures must match to the cent across documents, ledgers and return: in Pescara even the rounding was checked.
- Request annulment in self-review, without stopping the appeal. A self-review request can cite the 2016 Joint Divisions and the later case law, but it does not suspend the 60-day deadline. It is filed alongside the appeal, not instead of it.
- Build the appeal on evidence, not only on principle. The legal principle is now settled; what wins the case is the demonstration, document by document, of the substantive requirements and of timeliness against the two-year term. It is also worth stressing, as the judge did, that the office did not dispute the substance.
- Weigh the value of the dispute. Below 3,000 euro a lawyer is not compulsory and the court fee is 30 euro; between 3,000 and 5,000 euro a single judge decides. A 6,000 euro credit justifies the appeal when the documentation is complete, because costs follow the event.
After the judgment: how to collect the refund
A favourable first-instance judgment does not close the matter by itself. Three steps make the difference between a principle affirmed and a bank transfer received.
Serve the judgment on the office at once. The appeal must be lodged within 60 days of service of the judgment (art. 51 of Legislative Decree 546/1992) or, if neither party serves it, within six months of filing (art. 38(3)). Serving the judgment at the taxpayer’s initiative cuts the period of uncertainty from six months to two: if the Agency does not appeal, the judgment becomes final sooner and the refund becomes definitive.
Ask for enforcement. Judgments ordering payment of sums to the taxpayer are immediately enforceable (art. 69 of Legislative Decree 546/1992); for amounts above 10,000 euro the judge may make payment conditional on a guarantee. If the office does not comply within 90 days of service of the judgment, compliance proceedings can be requested (art. 70). Interest on the refund runs from the claim.
Keep the accounts open. Until the judgment is final, it is wise not to carry the credit into other returns or offset it, to avoid challenges of double use; and to check that the office has not meanwhile issued an informal notice or a payment demand on the same excess, to be challenged or suspended by reference to the judgment.
| Step | Deadline | Reference |
|---|---|---|
| Annual VAT return | 30 April; up to 90 days later it is late but valid | art. 8 Presidential Decree 322/1998; art. 2(7) |
| Return more than 90 days late | Omitted for formal purposes; fixed penalty if no tax is due | art. 2(7) Presidential Decree 322/1998; art. 5 Legislative Decree 471/1997 |
| Credit from a late VAT return | Recognised if proven and claimed by the return for the second following year | Cass. Joint Divisions 17757/2016; Cass. 3066/2023 |
| Appeal against the denial | 60 days from service of the denial | arts. 19 and 21 Legislative Decree 546/1992 |
| Appeal against the judgment | 60 days from service of the judgment or 6 months from filing | arts. 38 and 51 Legislative Decree 546/1992 |
| Enforcement of the judgment | Immediate; compliance proceedings 90 days after service | arts. 69 and 70 Legislative Decree 546/1992 |
The full judgment
Judgment no. 772/2026 of the first-instance tax court of Pescara, Section 1, filed on 26 October 2026, is available here in an anonymised version (Italian): the data of the appellant company, of its representatives and counsel, of its commercial counterparties and all references that would allow the persons involved to be identified have been redacted. The panel, the reasoning and the operative part are unabridged.
Download judgment CGT Pescara no. 772/2026 (PDF, anonymised version, Italian). At the date of publication the judgment is not final: the time limits for appeal are running.
Frequently asked questions on late VAT returns and refunds in Italy
If I file the Italian VAT return more than 90 days late, do I lose the credit?
No, according to Supreme Court case law and the Pescara judgment. A late VAT return is omitted for formal purposes and the penalty applies, but the VAT credit arises from the transactions and remains due if its substantive requirements are proven and it is claimed by the deadline of the return for the second following year. The Agency, however, tends to deny it at administrative level: as a rule, an appeal is needed.
Can the credit from a late VAT return be carried forward or offset?
The Agency disputes it and, if carried forward, issues an informal notice recovering the excess. The safest route is a documented refund claim, followed by an appeal against any denial. Carrying forward or offsetting exposes you to a payment demand and penalties, even if the credit is later recognised in court.
How long do I have to challenge a VAT refund denial in Italy?
60 days from service of the denial, on pain of inadmissibility. If the office does not reply to the refund claim, an appeal against the silence can be lodged after 90 days from the claim, until the right is time-barred. The procedure is that of ordinary tax litigation in Italy, with a court fee based on the value.
Does this apply to foreign companies registered in Italy too?
Yes: the appellant was precisely an EU company directly registered in Italy. For non-residents there is also the refund procedure under art. 38-ter of Presidential Decree 633/1972 through the portal of the State of establishment, with its own deadlines, but those registered in Italy who have filed the annual return follow the ordinary rules of art. 30.
Is the judgment final?
No. It is a first-instance judgment filed on 26 October 2026; the Agency can appeal within 60 days of service or within six months of filing. We will update this page when the time limits have expired or in case of appeal.
What if the Agency does not pay after the judgment?
Judgments ordering a refund are immediately enforceable. After 90 days from service of the judgment without payment, compliance proceedings can be requested from the same court, which appoints a commissioner if necessary and orders the office to pay further costs.
Sources
- Presidential Decree 22 July 1998, no. 322, art. 2(7) (returns filed more than 90 days late) and art. 8 (VAT return)
- Presidential Decree 26 October 1972, no. 633, arts. 19, 30, 38-bis and 38-ter (VAT deduction and refunds)
- Legislative Decree 18 December 1997, no. 471, art. 5 (penalties for omitted VAT return)
- Legislative Decree 31 December 1992, no. 546, arts. 19, 21, 38, 51, 69 and 70 (appealable acts, deadlines, enforceability and compliance)
- Court of Cassation, Joint Divisions, 8 September 2016, no. 17757; Section V, 1 February 2023, no. 3066; Section V, order 6 May 2024, no. 12250 (Italgiure database)
- Court of Justice of the EU, C-146/05 Collée; C-332/15 Astone; C-580/16 Firma Hans Bühler; C-80/20 Wilo Salmson France; C-247/21 Luxury Trust Automobil
- Department of Tax Justice, Guide to the tax process and database of first- and second-instance case law
- First-instance tax court of Pescara, Section 1, judgment 19 October 2026, no. 772/2026, filed 26 October 2026 (anonymised version)
A VAT refund denial based only on a late VAT return is formally correct and substantively unfounded: the kind of act that, with the documents in order, is worth challenging. The Pescara judgment confirms it and shows the method: proof of the substantive requirements, respect of the two-year term, appeal within 60 days and, after winning, service of the judgment to close the timeline.
Received a VAT refund denial in Italy?
We check within days whether the credit can be defended and prepare the appeal
Studio Savia assists Italian businesses and foreign companies registered for VAT in Italy with VAT refunds and the litigation that follows. Send us the denial and the return: the first assessment is free.
Send the denial →Prefer to talk it through? Call the firm on +39 011 349 0809 (Mon–Fri 8:30 am–1:00 pm / 2:00–5:30 pm CET) or message us on WhatsApp.
