When an Italian tax audit uncovers evaded taxes above the criminal thresholds, criminal proceedings run alongside the tax proceedings, and the first measure the public prosecutor asks the judge for is a preventive seizure (sequestro preventivo) aimed at confiscation: bank accounts, real estate and shareholdings are frozen for an amount equal to the evaded tax. Many taxpayers then settle with the tax authorities through a tax settlement agreement (accertamento con adesione) and pay what is due, only to discover that the seizure remains in place, because the criminal judge reasons on the amount originally claimed.
In judgment no. 27741/2025 the Italian Supreme Court (Corte di Cassazione, Third Criminal Section) made clear that this is not how it works: once the amount agreed with the Revenue Agency has been paid in full, the profit of the crime no longer exists and the preventive seizure must be lifted. This guide explains the case, the principles, what changes with instalment plans after the 2024 reform and the cases in which payment is not enough. It is relevant for foreign-owned companies and their Italian directors, who are often the target of these measures.
In brief
- In proceedings for unfaithful tax return (Article 4 of Legislative Decree 74/2000) covering the years 2014 to 2020, the Court of Bari had ordered a preventive seizure of the taxpayer’s assets. The taxpayer then settled the years 2016 to 2020 through a tax settlement agreement, paying about 1.58 million euro.
- The Court nonetheless kept the seizure on more than 1.13 million for the settled years and on about 100,000 euro for 2014, holding that the criminal judge is not bound by the agreement with the tax authorities.
- The Cassazione (judgment no. 27741/2025) quashed without referral the seizure for a total of 1.23 million: full payment of the debt settled by agreement extinguishes the profit of the crime, and keeping the freeze would amount to double punishment. For 2014 it applied retroactively the more favourable criminal threshold of 150,000 euro.
- Since 2024, Article 12-bis of Legislative Decree 74/2000, as amended by Legislative Decree 87/2024, provides that the seizure cannot be ordered if the debt is being paid off through a regular instalment plan, unless there is a concrete risk that assets will be dispersed (Cass. crim. 21539/2026).
- Payment is not enough, however, for the crime of fraudulent evasion of tax collection (Article 11): there the profit is the value of the assets removed from the reach of the tax authorities, not the tax (Cass. crim. 1643/2026).
Table of contents
How preventive seizure works for Italian tax crimes
Article 12-bis of Legislative Decree 74/2000 provides that, upon conviction or plea bargain for a tax crime, confiscation of the assets constituting the profit or price of the crime is always ordered or, where this is not possible, confiscation by equivalent of the offender’s assets for a corresponding value. To prevent the assets from disappearing in the meantime, the public prosecutor asks the preliminary investigations judge for a preventive seizure aimed at confiscation (Article 321 of the Code of Criminal Procedure), already at the investigation stage.
For tax return offences, such as fraudulent or unfaithful returns, the profit coincides with the tax saving, that is the evaded tax. Direct seizure hits the money of the company that benefited from the evasion; seizure by equivalent, if the company’s assets are insufficient, hits the personal assets of the director or of the individual taxpayer. The amount is usually based on the tax audit report of the Guardia di Finanza or the Revenue Agency, often built also on bank investigations, and therefore on the highest amounts claimed during the audit.
The critical point is the relationship with the tax proceedings. Under the “double track” principle (Article 20 of Legislative Decree 74/2000) the two proceedings are independent: the criminal judge establishes the crime under its own rules, without being bound by what has been decided or agreed in the tax proceedings. But confiscation, and therefore preventive seizure, serves to take away the profit: if the profit is returned to the State, what is left to confiscate? This is the question answered by judgment 27741/2025. For an overview of the crimes and thresholds see our guide on tax crimes in Italy.
The case: preventive seizure for unfaithful tax return and a tax settlement agreement
On 23 February 2022 the Court of Bari ordered a preventive seizure against a taxpayer under investigation for unfaithful tax return, the crime under Article 4 of Legislative Decree 74/2000, for the tax years 2014 to 2020. In the meantime the taxpayer had settled the years 2016 to 2020 with the Revenue Agency through a tax settlement agreement, paying a total of 1,576,440.76 euro in taxes, penalties and interest. On the basis of the payment he asked for the seizure to be lifted.
By order of 27 January 2025 the Court rejected the request and kept the freeze on 1,132,114.27 euro for the years 2016 to 2020 and on 100,242 euro for 2014. The reasoning was the traditional double-track one: the criminal judge is not bound by the agreement reached with the tax authorities and can continue to treat the amount originally claimed, higher than the settled one, as profit. The taxpayer appealed to the Cassazione.
What the Cassazione decided on preventive seizure in judgment 27741/2025
The Court upheld the first two grounds of appeal, for breach of Articles 12-bis and 20 of Legislative Decree 74/2000 and for the application of the criminal threshold, and quashed without referral the seizure for a total of 1,232,356.27 euro. The reasoning has four steps.
Full payment extinguishes the profit of the crime
The profit of tax return offences coincides with the debt owed to the State. If the debt has been extinguished by full payment of the amount agreed in the settlement, including penalties and interest, there is no enrichment left to confiscate. The Court recalls a settled principle: the preventive seizure of assets is justified only until the evaded sums are recovered (Cass. 46726/2012 and 6635/2014). Keeping the preventive seizure after payment would amount to double punishment, with the State collecting the same sum twice.
The double track does not determine the confiscable profit
The double track remains valid for establishing whether the crime was committed: the criminal judge may find that the evaded tax was higher than the settled amount and convict, if the thresholds are exceeded. But it does not apply mechanically to determining the confiscable profit. The tax settlement agreement is a public-law agreement that determines the tax claim definitively (Cass. 16675/2022): once that claim has been satisfied, the criminal judge cannot seek to confiscate a difference that the State no longer has any right to claim.
Article 12-bis, paragraph 2: a further argument
Article 12-bis, paragraph 2, provides that confiscation does not apply to the part that the taxpayer undertakes to pay to the State, even where there is a seizure. The Court draws an a fortiori argument: if confiscation is excluded already by a mere undertaking to pay, it is all the more excluded when payment has been made in full. The same conclusion had been reached by Cass. 32282/2024, in a case where two entrepreneurs had paid the settled amount and the review court had kept a seizure of over 3 million.
The more favourable threshold for 2014
For 2014, which had not been settled, the Court found that the evaded tax did not exceed the criminal threshold of 150,000 euro, applicable retroactively as the more favourable law under Article 2 of the Criminal Code. Without a crime there can be no preventive seizure: the 100,242 euro freeze fell as well.
Instalment plans and preventive seizure: what has changed since 2024
Judgment 27741/2025 concerns full payment. Very often, however, the settlement ends with an instalment plan: can the preventive seizure remain in that case? Until 2024 the case law was mostly strict: the undertaking to pay suspends confiscation, but only actual payment removes the power to confiscate for good, and the seizure could be maintained for the part not yet paid (among others, Cass. 40793/2019, 32213/2018 and 10120/2010).
Legislative Decree 87/2024, as part of the reform of tax penalties, amended Article 12-bis, paragraph 2: seizure aimed at confiscation cannot be ordered if the tax debt is being paid off through an instalment plan, including after conciliation or a tax settlement agreement, and the taxpayer is up to date with payments, unless there is a concrete risk that the assets securing the debt will be dispersed. The Cassazione, in judgment no. 21539 of 17 March 2026, applied the rule and annulled a seizure ordered despite a regularly honoured instalment plan, specifying that the risk of dispersion must be inferred from the taxpayer’s income, assets and financial situation, not asserted in the abstract.
The protection is not automatic. The Guardia di Finanza recommends informing the Public Prosecutor’s Office promptly of the settlement and the instalment plan, so that the prosecutor takes them into account before requesting the preventive seizure. And if instalments are not paid, confiscation is always ordered for the unpaid part.
When payment is not enough: fraudulent evasion of tax collection
The principle of judgment 27741/2025 applies to crimes where the profit coincides with the evaded or unpaid tax. It does not apply to fraudulent evasion of tax collection (Article 11 of Legislative Decree 74/2000), that is to anyone who sells assets fictitiously or carries out fraudulent acts on them to frustrate collection. The Cassazione, in judgment no. 1643 of 15 January 2026, clarified that for this crime the profit is not the tax debt but the value of the assets removed from the reach of the State.
Two consequences follow. The preventive seizure for fraudulent evasion of collection and the one for the underlying tax crime, for example failure to pay withholding taxes, are distinct and may coexist, provided each relates to the profit of its own crime and respects proportionality. And payment of the debt or use of settlement tools does not automatically lift the seizure for fraudulent evasion: according to the Court, a different solution would have anything but a deterrent effect.
Payment and criminal liability: Articles 13 and 13-bis
Payment affects the penalty too, not only the seizure. Article 13 of Legislative Decree 74/2000 provides for non-punishability for failure-to-pay offences (Articles 10-bis, 10-ter and 10-quater, paragraph 1) if the debt is paid before the trial opens, and for tax return offences (Articles 2, 3, 4 and 5) if full payment is made through voluntary disclosure (ravvedimento operoso) or a late return before the taxpayer has had formal notice of inspections, audits or proceedings. When the audit has already started, as in the case decided, Article 13-bis applies: if the debts are extinguished by full payment before the trial opens, including after a settlement agreement, penalties are reduced by up to half and ancillary penalties do not apply.
In short, those who settle and pay obtain three distinct effects: reduced tax penalties, the lifting of the preventive seizure and a significant mitigating factor in the criminal trial. But actual non-punishability for tax return offences requires payment before the audit has started.
What to do if there is a preventive seizure for tax crimes
- Coordinate the tax and criminal defence immediately. The discussion on the tax audit report, the settlement and the criminal strategy must be decided together: the amount agreed with the tax authorities becomes the basis for asking for the seizure to be lifted or reduced.
- Consider a tax settlement agreement. It reduces tax penalties to one third of the minimum and fixes the debt definitively. If the amount claimed is inflated, the settlement can also reduce the profit that can be seized; if the act has serious defects, it must be weighed against a tax appeal.
- Pay in full, if possible, and request release. With the receipt of full payment, file an application to lift the seizure with the judge who ordered it, citing judgment 27741/2025 and Cass. 32282/2024. If it is rejected, file an appeal before the review court or to the Cassazione.
- If paying in instalments, inform the Prosecutor’s Office. File the instalment plan and receipts, relying on Article 12-bis, paragraph 2, as amended in 2024 and on Cass. 21539/2026, and document the soundness of the assets to rule out the risk of dispersion.
- Check the thresholds year by year. Criminal thresholds have changed over time: for facts before 2019 the more favourable one may apply. A year below the threshold cannot be subject to seizure.
- Distinguish the crimes. If fraudulent evasion of collection is also alleged, paying the debt is not enough: work must focus on the value of the assets removed and on the proportionality of the freeze.
| Situation | Effect on the preventive seizure | Reference |
|---|---|---|
| Full payment after settlement agreement | Profit extinguished: the seizure must be lifted | Cass. crim. 27741/2025; Cass. 32282/2024 |
| Criminal amount higher than settled amount | The double track does not justify seizing the difference | Art. 20 Legislative Decree 74/2000; Cass. 27741/2025 |
| Undertaking to pay | Confiscation does not apply to the part covered by the undertaking | Art. 12-bis(2) Legislative Decree 74/2000 |
| Regular instalment plan in progress | Seizure not available unless there is a concrete risk of dispersion | Art. 12-bis(2) as amended by Legislative Decree 87/2024; Cass. crim. 21539/2026 |
| Instalments not paid | Confiscation always ordered for the unpaid part | Art. 12-bis(2) |
| Year below the criminal threshold | No crime, no seizure | Art. 2 Criminal Code; thresholds of Art. 4 Legislative Decree 74/2000 |
| Fraudulent evasion of collection (Art. 11) | Paying the debt does not lift the freeze | Cass. crim. 1643/2026 |
| Payment before the trial opens | Penalty reduced by up to half, no ancillary penalties | Art. 13-bis Legislative Decree 74/2000 |
Frequently asked questions on preventive seizure and tax settlements
If I pay the settled amount, is the preventive seizure lifted automatically?
Not automatically: an application to lift it must be filed with the judge, attaching the settlement agreement and the payment receipts. But according to the Cassazione, once full payment is proven, the judge must lift the freeze, because the profit of the crime no longer exists. A rejection can be appealed.
Can the criminal judge find that the evaded tax was higher than the settled amount?
Yes, for the purpose of establishing the crime. The double track allows the criminal judge to assess the evaded tax independently to decide whether the crime exists. But it cannot keep the preventive seizure on the difference between the amount claimed and the amount settled and paid, because confiscation serves to recover the profit, not to punish twice.
What if I asked to pay the settled amount in instalments?
Since 2024 the seizure cannot be ordered if instalments are paid regularly, unless there is a concrete risk of asset dispersion, which must be proven on the basis of the taxpayer’s economic situation. If the seizure is already in place, a regular instalment plan is an argument for having it lifted or reduced. If instalments are not paid, confiscation becomes possible again.
Can the preventive seizure hit the director’s personal assets?
Yes, through seizure by equivalent, but only if the assets of the company that benefited from the evasion are insufficient. Payment of the debt by the company extinguishes the profit also for the purposes of seizure by equivalent on the director’s assets. This is a frequent issue for foreign groups whose Italian subsidiaries are managed by local directors.
Does the settlement spare me the criminal trial?
Not always. For tax return offences non-punishability requires payment before the taxpayer has had formal notice of the audit. If the audit has already started, full payment before the trial opens still brings a substantial reduction of the penalty and excludes ancillary penalties (Article 13-bis), as well as the lifting of the preventive seizure.
Does it also apply to unpaid VAT or withholding taxes?
Yes, the profit coincides with the unpaid tax, so payment extinguishes it. For these crimes, moreover, full payment before the trial opens makes the offence non-punishable (Article 13, paragraph 1). The full range of defence tools, from the pre-assessment hearing to the trial, is in our guide on tax litigation in Italy.
Sources
- Euroconference News, L’incidenza dell’accertamento con adesione sul sequestro preventivo (commentary on Cass. 27741/2025, in Italian)
- LexCED, Confisca reati tributari: stop se il debito è pagato (Cass. crim. 32282/2024, in Italian)
- Diritto Bancario, Inammissibile la misura cautelare in pendenza di rateizzazione con l’Erario (Cass. crim. 21539/2026, in Italian)
- Osservatorio Giustizia Tributaria, Confisca e sequestro nei reati tributari (Cass. crim. 1643/2026, in Italian)
- Legislative Decree no. 74 of 10 March 2000, Articles 4, 11, 12-bis, 13, 13-bis and 20
- Legislative Decree no. 87 of 14 June 2024, reform of the tax penalty system
Preventive seizure for Italian tax crimes serves to ensure that the State recovers what was evaded, not to punish twice. Judgment 27741/2025 says so clearly: once the debt settled by agreement is paid in full, the freeze must be lifted even if the criminal judge considers the evasion to have been higher. Since 2024 the same logic protects those who pay regularly in instalments. To achieve these effects, however, the tax and criminal defence must work together from the tax audit report onwards.
Facing a preventive seizure for Italian tax crimes, or an audit report above the thresholds?
We coordinate settlement, payment and release of the seizure
Studio Savia assists companies, foreign groups and taxpayers in the discussion of the audit report, the tax settlement agreement and the planning of payments and instalment plans, in coordination with criminal counsel, to obtain the lifting or reduction of the seizure. The initial review is free of charge.
Request a review →Prefer to talk it through? Call the firm on +39 011 349 0809 (Mon–Fri 8:30 am–1:00 pm / 2:00–5:30 pm CET) or message us on WhatsApp.
