When a company has its registered office abroad but its shareholders, financing and part of its contracts are in Italy, the Agenzia delle Entrate often alleges “esterovestizione”, a fictitious foreign residence: it argues that the place of effective management is in Italy and that the company must pay Italian corporate income tax and VAT. The Italian Supreme Court (Corte di Cassazione), with decision no. 7694 of 30 March 2026, set a clear limit to this challenge: it is not enough to show that management impulses come from Italy or that the foreign structure produces a tax advantage.
The tax office must prove that the foreign company is a wholly artificial arrangement, lacking economic substance. If the foreign company has premises, assets, employees and corporate bodies that really meet abroad, the foreign residence stands, even where decisions are influenced by Italian persons. This guide explains the case, the Court’s reasoning, what changes with the new definition of residence in force since 2024, and how to build the evidence of foreign substance.
In brief
- An Italian company supplied ship-management services to a company incorporated in Portugal with its seat in Funchal (Madeira). The Agency argued that the customer was fictitiously resident abroad, with its place of effective management in Italy, so that the services supplied in 2011 were subject to Italian VAT.
- The tax court of Puglia excluded the fictitious residence: the Portuguese company had an operating seat, two Portuguese-flagged tugboats, 52 non-Italian employees trained in Lisbon, board and shareholders’ meetings held in Madeira, and taxes paid in Portugal.
- The Supreme Court dismissed the Agency’s appeal: the office’s approach was “atomistic”, focused on Italian de facto directors and service contracts, without proving that the foreign structure was fictitious. The managerial role of Italian persons, on its own, does not prove a place of effective management in Italy.
- The principle comes from EU law: freedom of establishment allows a company to choose the most favourable Member State and may be restricted only for wholly artificial arrangements (CJEU Cadbury Schweppes C-196/04, Planzer C-73/06, Edil Work 2 C-276/22). There is no general presumption of abuse merely because part of the activity takes place in another State.
- Since 2024, corporate residence in Italy rests on the registered office, the place of effective management and the place where ordinary management is mainly carried out (art. 73(3) of the Italian Income Tax Code, as amended by Legislative Decree 209/2023): the new definitions make proof of where decisions are taken and where day-to-day management happens even more central.
Contents
What the place of effective management is and why it decides residence
A company is tax resident in Italy, and therefore taxed here on its worldwide income, if for most of the tax period it has in Italy one of the connecting factors listed in art. 73(3) of the Income Tax Code (TUIR). Until 2023 the criteria were the registered office, the seat of administration and the main object.
From the 2024 tax period, under art. 2 of Legislative Decree 209/2023, the criteria are the registered office, the place of effective management and the place where ordinary management is mainly carried out. The place of effective management is defined by the law as the place where the strategic decisions concerning the company as a whole are taken on a continuous and coordinated basis; ordinary management is the place of the continuous and coordinated performance of day-to-day management acts.
Esterovestizione is the situation in which a company formally resident abroad in fact has its place of effective management or its ordinary management in Italy: the form is foreign, the substance is Italian. The consequences of a place of effective management in Italy are heavy, because the company is treated as if it had never filed returns in Italy: corporate income tax (IRES) and regional tax (IRAP) on all income, VAT on its transactions, penalties for failure to file and, above the thresholds, the criminal offence of failure to file.
For the general picture of the indicators used by the Agency and the Guardia di Finanza and of the available defences, see our guide on esterovestizione and hidden permanent establishment in Italy. Here we focus on one specific point: who must prove what, and when the proof is sufficient.
The case: ship-management services to a Madeira company with a disputed place of effective management
The dispute arose in Puglia. An Italian company supplied ship-management services to a company incorporated under Portuguese law with its seat in Funchal, on the island of Madeira, active in deep-sea towage and offshore platform assistance. According to the Agenzia delle Entrate the Portuguese company was resident in Portugal only on paper: the shareholders were Italian, decisions came from Italy, and the service contracts with the Italian companies showed that management was centralised here. From this premise the office drew a consequence for the Italian supplier’s VAT: if the customer was in reality resident in Italy, the services supplied in 2011 were territorially relevant in Italy under art. 7-ter of Presidential Decree 633/1972, and Italian VAT should have been charged.
The same challenge had been raised, on the direct-tax side, directly against the Portuguese company and its de facto directors for the years 2005 to 2012. The courts of first and second instance had established a series of facts no longer open to debate before the Supreme Court: the operating seat in Funchal, two Portuguese-flagged tugboats, 52 non-Italian employees with documented contracts and duties, training courses and boarding procedures carried out in Lisbon, board and shareholders’ meetings held in Madeira, income taxes of the directors paid in Portugal. The tax court of Puglia had therefore excluded the fictitious residence, and the Agency appealed to the Supreme Court.
What the Supreme Court decided on the place of effective management in decision 7694/2026
The Court dismissed the Agency’s appeal and upheld the Puglia judgment. The reasoning develops in four steps that matter to anyone with a foreign company connected to Italy.
Seat of administration means effective seat
The Court reaffirms that the “seat of administration” in art. 73 TUIR, in the version applicable to the case, coincides with the effective seat, what the law now calls the place of effective management: the place where management activities are actually carried out and from which the essential impulse to the business originates.
If the foreign company is controlled by Italian persons, the office must show that it is a mere screen and that the Italian shareholders have in fact taken over its management. The mere de facto managerial role of Italian persons is not, on its own, sufficient. In other words, the question is not who influences the company, but whether a genuine autonomous economic organisation exists in the foreign State.
The tax advantage is not enough: a wholly artificial arrangement is required
To disregard the foreign residence it is not sufficient to point, in isolation, to the tax advantage that the location produces. It must be shown that the company is a purely artificial structure, lacking economic substance.
The Court relies on the EU case law on freedom of establishment: setting up a company in the Member State with the most favourable regime is a lawful choice, and a restriction is allowed only for wholly artificial arrangements aimed at escaping tax (Cadbury Schweppes), assessed on objective factors ascertainable by third parties such as premises, staff, equipment and real activity (Planzer). A general presumption of abuse, based solely on the fact that the company carries out a substantial part of its activity in another State, would be an automatism incompatible with EU law (Edil Work 2).
The office’s approach was atomistic
The Agency’s appeal focused on the role of the Italian persons and on the service contracts between the Portuguese company and the Italian ones, to show that management impulses came from Italy. The Court finds this approach atomistic and incomplete, because it does not address the decisive point: the actual existence of an operating structure in Portugal.
The assessment of the place of effective management must be comprehensive and consider the articles of association, the place of meetings, documentation, banking activity, staff, technical means and core business. The fact that some functions are outsourced to Italian companies under ship-management contracts does not deprive the foreign company of its substance: physiological direction and coordination within a group are one thing; total heterodirection that empties the foreign company is another.
The consequence for VAT
Once the fictitious residence is excluded, the Portuguese customer is a taxable person established outside Italy and the services supplied by the Italian provider are not territorially relevant in Italy: since 2010, general business-to-business services are taxed where the customer is established (art. 44 of Directive 2006/112/EC and art. 7-ter of Presidential Decree 633/1972). The VAT assessment therefore falls in its entirety. The Court also clarifies that this logic applies to tax periods from 2010 onwards, when the customer-location rule came into force.
Why the decision matters to anyone with a foreign company today
The decision belongs to a line of authority consolidated by the Supreme Court between 2025 and 2026: with judgments nos. 22901, 23543 and 24031 of 22 August 2025, concerning the same case on the direct-tax side, the Court had already held that freedom of establishment cannot be compressed by presumption, but only on serious, precise and consistent evidence of the simulated nature of the foreign establishment, and that ship-management contracts with Italian companies do not show a shift of strategic direction to Italy. Decision 7694/2026 closes the circle on VAT and reaffirms the criteria for the place of effective management already set by Cass. 1544/2023.
The practical point is the burden of proof. Two readings coexist in the case law: one treats esterovestizione as a form of abuse of law, to be proven through the artificial arrangement (Cass. 33234/2018, 4463/2022, 7454/2022, 8297/2022); the other treats it as an objective finding of residence, in which it is enough to prove one of the connecting factors in Italy without investigating any avoidance intent (Cass. 11709/2022, 11710/2022, 23150/2022, 25917/2024).
Decision 7694/2026 does not reject the second reading, but sets its minimum content: even when residence is established objectively, showing that the shareholders are Italian and that part of the decisions pass through Italy is not enough if a real structure exists abroad. The presumption in art. 73(5-bis) TUIR remains in place for foreign companies that control Italian companies and are in turn controlled by Italian residents or managed mostly by Italian residents: there it is the taxpayer who must prove the foreign roots.
With the new definition of residence in force since 2024 the proof becomes even more concrete: the place of effective management is the place of strategic decisions taken on a continuous and coordinated basis, and the main place of ordinary management is the place of day-to-day management acts. Both criteria are proven with facts, not with clauses in the articles of association. On how the office gathers those facts, from bank investigations to inspections at the Italian shareholders’ premises, see the guide on tax assessment powers in Italy.
How to document the place of effective management abroad
The decision offers, in the negative, a checklist of what convinced the judges. Anyone running a foreign company with Italian shareholders or partners should build and keep this documentation before any audit.
- Corporate bodies that really meet abroad. This is the main evidence of the place of effective management. Board and shareholders’ minutes with place, date, attendees and decisions; tickets, attendance registers, resolutions signed on site. Video-conference meetings must be minuted stating where each director is located.
- Directors with consistent residence and skills. Directors resident in the foreign State, taxed there, with real and not merely formal powers. If Italian directors exist, their acts must appear as the execution of decisions taken by the foreign body, not the other way round.
- Staff, assets and operating premises. Employment contracts, payslips, social contributions, training, premises with a lease and utilities, business assets registered in the foreign State (in the case decided, two Portuguese-flagged tugboats).
- Bank accounts and signatures. Accounts opened abroad with signing powers held by the foreign directors; movements consistent with the activity. An Italian account operated by the shareholders is one of the indicators most used by the office.
- Written, arm’s-length contracts with the Italian companies. If operating functions are entrusted to Italian companies, the service contracts must delimit the engagement, provide for market remuneration and leave strategic decisions to the foreign body. This is the distinction between physiological direction and coordination and total heterodirection.
- Taxes paid abroad. Returns and payments in the foreign State, certificates of tax residence, any local ruling. They do not prevent a challenge, but they weigh in the overall assessment and open the way to the mutual agreement procedure against double taxation.
This documentation is needed at two moments: in the preventive adversarial procedure, when the draft assessment arrives and there are 60 days to reply, and in the appeal, where the judge assesses the place of effective management with a comprehensive and not atomistic examination. Those who face an audit without these documents must reconstruct the substance after the event, with third-party statements and indirect evidence that are far less convincing.
What to do if the office alleges a place of effective management in Italy
- Check immediately the legal basis used by the office: tax year, connecting factor challenged (seat of administration up to 2023, place of effective management or ordinary management from 2024), any application of the presumption in paragraph 5-bis. The legal basis determines who must prove what.
- Contest the merits with a comprehensive examination: decision 7694/2026 is the precedent to cite when the office confines itself to Italian de facto directors, intra-group contracts and the tax advantage without showing that the foreign structure is fictitious.
- Check the procedural defects of the act: preventive adversarial procedure respected, notice signed after the 60 days from the tax audit report, reasoning consistent with the draft assessment. In esterovestizione cases the assessments are often the result of long audits and procedural errors are not rare.
- File a tax appeal in Italy within 60 days of service, considering a settlement only if the foreign substance is really weak: settling an esterovestizione assessment means accepting Italian residence for the following years as well.
- Check the criminal profile: failure to file due to esterovestizione amounts to the offence under art. 5 of Legislative Decree 74/2000 above 50,000 euros of evaded tax per tax, whereas abuse of law is not punishable (art. 10-bis(13) of Law 212/2000). The characterisation of the challenge, abuse or objective residence, therefore also affects the criminal side: see the guide on tax crimes in Italy. A criminal acquittal helps in the tax proceedings but does not bind them automatically.
- If the foreign company is genuinely rooted abroad but has an office or an agent in Italy, beware of the alternative challenge of a hidden permanent establishment: we discuss it in the case study on permanent establishment in Italy.
| Element | What it proves | Reference |
|---|---|---|
| Registered office abroad | Not enough on its own: a formal criterion that can be overcome | art. 73(3) TUIR |
| Place of effective management | Place of continuous and coordinated strategic decisions | art. 73(3) TUIR (Legislative Decree 209/2023); Cass. 1544/2023 |
| Ordinary management carried out mainly | Place of day-to-day management acts | art. 73(3) TUIR from 2024 |
| Presumption for foreign holdings | Burden of proof on the taxpayer if Italian control or board | art. 73(5-bis) TUIR |
| Wholly artificial arrangement | The only case in which freedom of establishment may be restricted | CJEU C-196/04, C-73/06, C-276/22; Cass. 7694/2026 |
| Italian de facto directors | Indicator not sufficient on its own | Cass. 7694/2026; Cass. 22901, 23543, 24031/2025 |
| Territoriality of B2B services for VAT | Place where the customer is established, since 2010 | art. 7-ter Presidential Decree 633/1972; art. 44 Directive 2006/112/EC |
Frequently asked questions on the place of effective management
If the shareholders of the foreign company are Italian, is the company automatically fictitiously resident abroad?
No. Control by Italian residents is an indicator and, for foreign companies that in turn control Italian companies, triggers the presumption in paragraph 5-bis with reversal of the burden of proof. But decision 7694/2026 clarifies that the office must show that the foreign company is a mere screen and that the shareholders have in fact taken over its management; the de facto managerial role of Italian persons is not enough if a real structure exists abroad.
Do board meetings held by video-conference from Italy move the place of effective management?
They can move the place of effective management, if they become the rule and the foreign directors merely ratify. The place of effective management is the place where strategic decisions are taken on a continuous and coordinated basis: if that place is, in fact, the Italian office of the shareholders, the criterion is met in Italy. That is why meetings should be held abroad, the physical location of the participants should be minuted and the foreign directors should hold real powers.
What changes with the 2024 reform compared with the seat of administration?
The place of effective management replaces the seat of administration with a more precise statutory definition, and ordinary management carried out mainly replaces the main object, which was an ambiguous criterion for holding companies. The principles of decision 7694/2026, grounded in EU law, remain valid: even under the new criteria the office cannot base the assessment on general presumptions of abuse.
Is entrusting functions to an Italian company under a service contract risky?
Not in itself. The Court recognised that ship-management contracts with Italian companies do not deprive the foreign company of its substance, provided the engagement is delimited, remunerated at market value and strategic decisions remain with the foreign body. The risk for the place of effective management arises when the Italian provider decides everything and the foreign company merely issues invoices.
Does a criminal acquittal for failure to file also close the tax dispute?
Not automatically. The Supreme Court, in the 2025 judgments on the same case, gave evidential weight to the criminal acquittal without holding that it automatically binds the tax proceedings, and in decision 7694/2026 it reaffirmed the two-track principle. The acquittal must therefore be filed and relied on, but the tax judge decides on the place of effective management under its own rules of evidence.
Does VAT always follow the residence of the customer company?
For general services between taxable persons, since 2010 VAT applies in the State where the customer is established: if the foreign company is not fictitiously resident abroad, the services supplied by an Italian provider are outside the scope of Italian VAT. If instead the fictitious residence is established, the Italian provider in turn risks a VAT assessment for not having charged the tax, as happened in the case decided. For the complete picture of the defence tools, from the adversarial procedure to trial, see the guide on tax litigation in Italy.
Sources
- Corte di Cassazione, no. 7694 of 30 March 2026 (summary by GM Tax, in Italian)
- VATupdate, Italian Supreme Court: a genuine Portuguese establishment puts B2B services outside Italian VAT (7 August 2026)
- Studio Gaeta, commentary on decision 7694/2026 (9 April 2026, in Italian)
- Cass., Tax Division, 22 August 2025, nos. 22901, 23543 and 24031 (commentary by Studio Legale Dal Piaz, in Italian)
- Presidential Decree 22 December 1986, no. 917, Income Tax Code (TUIR), art. 73(3) and (5-bis)
- Legislative Decree 27 December 2023, no. 209, art. 2 (new definition of corporate residence)
- Presidential Decree 26 October 1972, no. 633, art. 7-ter (place of supply of B2B services)
- CJEU, 12 September 2006, C-196/04, Cadbury Schweppes; CJEU, 28 June 2007, C-73/06, Planzer Luxembourg; CJEU, 25 April 2024, C-276/22, Edil Work 2
A registered office abroad does not protect, but Italian shareholders do not condemn either. Decision 7694/2026 moves the contest onto the right ground: the place of effective management is proven with verifiable facts, and those who have them on their side, premises, assets, people, meetings, accounts, taxes paid, can resist even an assessment on the place of effective management built on years of audits. Those who do not would do well to build them before the draft assessment arrives.
Do you have a foreign company with shareholders or partners in Italy, or an esterovestizione assessment?
We verify the substance of the structure and prepare the defence
Studio Savia assists groups, foreign companies and entrepreneurs in documenting the place of effective management, in the preventive adversarial procedure and in appeals against esterovestizione assessments. The first assessment is free.
Request an assessment →Prefer to talk it through? Call the firm on +39 011 349 0809 (Mon–Fri 8:30 am–1:00 pm / 2:00–5:30 pm CET) or message us on WhatsApp.
